Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Review of the Day: Knuckleheads by Joan Holub

By Joan Holub
Illustrated by Michael Slack
Chronicle Books
ISBN: 978-0-8118-5523-5
Ages 4-8
On shelves now

Puns. Puns are hard. I think that it’s safe to say that every adult has a kind of pun-limit. We can only take so many of them until we hit that limit and our groans turn from humored acknowledgments of cleverness to real moans of pain. Of course this limit is entirely reliant on the quality of the puns at hand, particularly when you’re dealing with picture books. Now we turn our attention to Knuckleheads by Joan Holub, as illustrated by Michael Slack. As I read through the book I found my pun limit thwarted time and time again. The sheer weirdness of the concept combined with the four storylines . . . well, basically this is like nothing you’ve ever seen (let alone dreamed up) before. You can’t deny it. If fairytales were performed entirely by sentient isolated body parts, this is certainly how their stories would go.

Four stories, all held together by a single green-skinned witch. Four stories, all based on famous fairy tales, in which the characters have been replaced with hands, feet, noses, thumbs, and other extreme extremities. In the first tale "Handsel and Gretel" two troublemakers outwit an evil witch. The witch is caught, but escapes into the next story "Handerella" where she masquerades as the little hand’s evil stepmother. Instead of a beautiful gown, Handerella goes to the ball in an evening glove with a ring (toe-pazz?) and when she runs away in the night the prince ("Finger Prints") tries to find the lady in the kingdom that will fit the ring. Foiled once more the witch briefly participates in Thumbelina (it’s a short tale, haha) and then becomes the evil queen in "Nose White". And even when this story finishes, however, she’s bound for other tales like "Paul Bunion" and "The Adventures of Tom Thumb" to wreck havoc everywhere.

I would not have imagined the sheer amount of hand-based puns a single human brain is capable of producing. Mood rings, finger food, thumb wrestling, brass knuckles . . . basically if you can think of some kind of hand-based pun it’s in here. After reading Handsel and Gretel I was convinced that Holub had done all she could, and maybe that was partly true. But about the time you come to the tale of "Handerella" and her evil foot-based stepsisters, that’s when things go from merely weird to downright bizarre. Now the foot jokes come out as well (though there’s certainly enough hand-based entertainment to go around too). And then when Snow White becomes Nose White… you get the picture. But somehow it actually works. I mean they’re all pretty funny to read through and the stories hold together. For all its insane anarchistic look and feel, this is a competent series of fractured tales. Though obviously you’d have to hand it to a kid who already knew the stories already and would be able to get the jokes.

The sheer amount of details in this book visually are also staggering. In fact, I had to start wondering at some point whether or not illustrator Michael Slack gave any suggestions of his own on some of these details. I mean, did Holub come up with Nose White being sent into a grove of "palm trees" (oh heavens) or Slack? Did Slack come up with the image of the witch peering one side of the cover, showing up face-first on the back of the book? Did he have the foresight to come up with the hands using sign language to spell out the word "love" while Handerella’s fingers do the same on top of her head? Whatever his contributions, Slack’s art is completely computer generated, though you might not be aware of that fact at first. The look of the book is meant to conjure up images of classic fairy tale novels. Hence you get some pretty endpapers with a classic pattern on the front (interrupted by the characters at the back). After that, however, it’s pretty raucous. I will say that even though the book has a hand-drawn look at times, people who are not fans of computer generated illustration would do best to steer clear of this puppy. It may be a little too smooth for their tastes.

The whole characters-as-body parts style is pretty touch and go (ho ho), however. There’s a bit of inconsistency to it at times. For example, why does Handerella’s stylized dog have three finger-like ears? Why will some characters have faces and others just have eyes on their fingers? Why can some hands be people while others, like the one-hand band, be five characters with each finger a person? And why am I even asking any of this? Honestly, I don’t suppose it even matters. If you can swallow the logic that thumbs are capable of taking a turn about the room on their own little legs, the rest of Slack’s crazy logic should suffice.

In my experience, kids deal with weird stuff in books with a lot more grace and appreciation than their adult contemporaries. Hand a kid Garmann’s Summer for example, and they’ll get into it. Hand that same book to an adult and watch them cringe. This book won’t make any grown-ups quiver but it’s certainly going to be interesting trying to sell it to them. "Okay it’s fairy tales only they’re more like fractured fairy tales and all the characters are body parts. With legs." Oh yeah. That’s gonna go down like a dream with some of my more staid and unimaginative patrons. Basically this is going to appeal to fans of Scieszka’s The Stinky Cheese Man both in terms of content and design. Heck, I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that Stinky Cheese Man was the original inspiration for the layout of this tale. Both stories break down the fourth wall with great frequency, and they’ve a similar feel in terms of bizarre content and twisted senses of humor. Clearly this is not going to be like anything else on your shelf, though. It’s an amusing ride with a style and charm entirely of its own.

On shelves now.

Other Blog Reviews:

Other Blog Mentions:


About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.


  1. teacherninja says:

    Sounds screwy to me, but the illustrations look great. I’ll definitely check it out.

  2. Joan Holub says:

    Thank you so much for reading and reviewing KNUCKLEHEADS in your blog, Elizabeth!

    The witches in many fairy tales all seem the same to me, but other characters, such as Hansel and Gretel or Cinderella, are obviously quite different. That’s why, as you noted, I had the same witch slipping from tale to tale in KNUCKLEHEADS. In fact, that was the initial inspiration for the book. Then came the play on words—making the characters hands (Handerella, etc.) Why have a new witch for each fairy tale, when the same green, warty gal will do?

    To answer your art ponderings, there was certainly a give and take between illustrator Michael Slack and me. For instance, I came up with Nose White being sent into a grove of “palm trees,” but Michael came up with the image of the witch peering out of the inside back cover, and showing up face-first on the outside back cover. I came up with the hands using sign language to spell out the word “love” along the sides of the Handerella-at-the-ball page, but Michael came up with having Handerella’s fingers do the same on top of her head. You’re more observant than I because–as many, many times as I pored over the sketches and art during the creation of KNUCKLEHEADS–I didn’t even notice that until you mentioned it!

  3. Pam & Paula says:

    Interesting. Thanks for the info on a book we hadn’t heard about. Always looking for fresh books for our fractured fairy tale unit.

  4. Jaime Temairik says:

    I love KNUCKLEHEADS! My pun-limit never got knocked down after puberty, so I’m ready for a sequel already. Thank heavens none of Slack’s buildings had flying buttresses, though.

    Joan used to be a Washingtonian and we miss her. Go, Joan, go!

    Have to HAND it to you (Zing!), Betsy, for a lovely review.

  5. Don’t forget that Joan is also a wonderful picture book illustrator too. Way to go!

  6. Man, what GORGEOUS illustrations. A weird, cool book. Luv it. Thanks, Joan, for sharing some inside scoop.