Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Top 100 Children’s Novels (#45-41)

goldencompass Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)#45 The Golden Compass by Philip Pullman (1995)
(#1)(#2)(#2)(#3)(#3)(#4)(#4)(#
5)(#5)(#5)(#7)(#7)(#8)(#8)(#9) – 92 points

Astonishing, sweeping adventure, unforgettable characters and images and Milton! - Janice E. Bojda, Head of Children’s Services, Evanston Public Library

Spunky heroine! Religion and church hierarchies, and the conflict between the two! Cleverness! Misbehaving! Cobbling a family together when you’ve lost yours. - Miriam Newman

Another game-changer, for me: this one is comfortable with ambiguity in a way that still feels radical to me in a children’s book. By the end of the series good and evil get sorted out (a little too comfortably for my taste) but in this everything’s still up in the air. Lyra is a work of genius–a worthy successor to Alice. - Libby Gruner

For the first time I need to make a titular decision. Do I stay with the Yankee moniker "The Golden Compass" and list the book that way, or do I reach back to the book’s original British roots and call it "Northern Lights", as was originally intended? Since I didn’t decide to list Pippi Longstocking (#95 on the list) as Boken Om Pippi Langstrump, I’ll continue to name the books here under their Americanized names. I am, after all, a Yankee.

The synopsis from the publisher reads, "The action follows 11-year-old protagonist Lyra Belacqua, accompanied by her daemon, from her home at Oxford University to the frozen wastes of the North, on a quest to save kidnapped children from the evil ‘Gobblers,’ who are using them as part of a sinister experiment. Lyra also must rescue her father from the Panserbjorne, a race of talking, armored, mercenary polar bears holding him captive. Joining Lyra are a vagabond troop of gyptians (gypsies), witches, an outcast bear, and a Texan in a hot air balloon."

I may have come to the adult world of children’s literature thanks to Harry Potter, but it was Pullman who pulled me in the rest of the way.  Living in Portland, Oregon shortly after graduating college (a lovely town to live in, but not ideal for the penniless post-student) I spent a lot of time in Powell’s Bookstore.  One day I read an article in the paper that was accompanied by an image of a large cat boxing with Harry Potter and winning.  The gist of the piece was that Harry was all well and good, but if you wanted some serious children’s literature you wanted to get your hands on the His Dark Materials books.  That’s how they sold Pullman’s series at the start.  Reviewers would contemptuously pooh-pooh the Harry Potter phenomenon in light of Pullman’s sophistication.  You weren’t supposed to like them both.  Many did.  And in the coffee shop portion of Powell’s I devoured all three books and found them gripping, each and every one.

The term "embarrassment of riches" comes to mind when searching for information about this book.  Particularly in terms of literary scholarship.  So the question becomes less, "what is there to say?" and more "what should I not bother to say?"  Let us begin at the very beginning then.

In a conversation with Leonard Marcus (found in the book The Wand in the Word: Conversations with Writers of Fantasy), Pullman describes the "lonely" process of writing the first two books, his dinner with Tolkien, and whether or not he had a plan in mind for the three books from the start. "Not a plan. But I knew what the story was going to be and where it was going to go and when it was going to end, and roughly how long it was going to be. I didn’t intend to write three books. I intended to write a long story. But it very quickly became evident that it would have to be published as three books because otherwise it would just sit on the shelves. It probably wouldn’t have gotten published. Who would publish a thirteen-hundred-page-long book for children?"

This statement actually helps better put into context this critique by Charles de Lint in the January 1997 edition of The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction:

"… for all its positive aspects, The Golden Compass falls prey to the same problem besetting too many fantasy novels that have appeared since Tolkien inadvertently invented the fantasy genre in the fifties: There is no closure because the book is only the first part of a trilogy. After four hundred pages, the plot simply peters out and the author expects readers to wait at least two more years to have the whole story in hand. Fantasy and sf are the only genres that charge their readers three times the cover price of a regular book to give them a compete story because. . .well, that’s how Tolkien did it, the irony being that The Lord of the Rings wasn’t written as a trilogy, but arbitrarily broken up into three books by its publisher. There’s nothing wrong with a series, or with continuing a theme from one book to another, but the author should at least play fair with his readers. The Golden Compass doesn’t do so, continuing the unfortunate trend."

Generally speaking, if you write a book in which the church is made up of crazed fanatics, even if it’s in an alternative world you’re going to find yourself at the receiving end of a bit of anger.  And he didn’t even kill off God in this one!  Yet as of September 2009, The Guardian reported that Philip Pullman was ranked second in the top ten books that people have tried to ban in America.

In the November 2007 issue of Kliatt, Marissa Elliot had a different idea of why folks may object to the books. "For many adults, the idea of introducing their children to an ambiguous world, even in literature, is disconcerting. It is easier to keep life simple, to save the questions for another day. Pullman’s writing has received some criticism and spurred concern from parents because, it is said, of the novel’s religious implications. But perhaps the fear is more basic in nature. Fantasy is generally predictable with a safe, triumphant conclusion and characters easily categorized as ‘villain’ or ‘hero.’ Not so with Pullman. Readers will find good people making horrendous mistakes and bad people making justifiable choices."

You may recall how pleased I was earlier on this list with artist Leighton Johns’ pulp horror cover of The Witches (#96). Well he did one for The Golden Compass as well, and as I see it, it’s pretty swell.


northern cover 72 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


This is also amusing.  A luxury item that completely misses the very point of what the golden compass even is.

Publishers Weekly said of it, "As always, Pullman is a master at combining impeccable characterizations and seamless plotting, maintaining a crackling pace to create scene upon scene of almost unbearable tension. This glittering gem will leave readers of all ages eagerly awaiting the next installment of Lyra’s adventures."

Said Kirkus , "Lyra may suffer from excessive spunk, but she is thorough, intelligent, and charming. The author’s care in recreating Victorian speech affectations never hinders the action; copious amounts of gore will not dissuade the squeamish, for resonating at the story’s center is the twinkling image of a celestial city. This first fantastic installment of the "His Dark Materials" trilogy propels readers along with horror and high adventure, a shattering tale that begins with a promise and delivers an entire universe."

Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books thought, "Treachery, tricks, Gypsies, polar bears, witches, and photography all play a part in the ambitious story, and Pullman is particularly inventive in the way he blends not-quite science with not-quite magic. Although the book sometimes seems overly cerebral–Lyra seems more a pawn to the plot than a personality, for example–the faithful (and sometimes nasty, depending on their humans) damons give it some heart."

Booklist said it was, "A totally involving, intricately plotted fantasy that will leave readers clamoring for the sequels."

Horn Book said, "Touching, exciting, and mysterious by turns, this is a splendid work."

And as School Library Journal put it, "There is some fine descriptive writing, filled with the kind of details that encourage suspension of disbelief. The story line moves along at a rapid clip, but flags when it delves into philosophical matters."

The different American covers abound.  This first one here will always be my favorite. 


db184310fca07e2026045010.L Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


0345413350.01.LZZZZZZZ Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


043999434901lzzzzzzz Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


gol Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


51ii8 oIlHL Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


compass 703381 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


1904 1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


And BridgetotheStars.net has a fantastic array of foreign covers for the book as well.  These include:


Britain

britnl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


adultnl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

junior nl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

n23213 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

NorthernLights Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

Brazil

braztgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Croatian


croatnl2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Czech


czetgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


czehdm1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Danish


dantgc1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Dutch


dutchnl2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


dutchnl1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Estonian


estonianl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


French


frenchnew1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


German


gertgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


gertgc2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


gertgc3 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Greek


greektgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Hebrew/Israeli


hebtgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Hungarian (interesting choice)


hungnl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


hungnl3 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Icelandic


icenl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Norwegian


norwtgc Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Polish

13 02a Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Portugese


portnl Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Russian


rusnl1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


rusnl2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Spain


spannl1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


spannl2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Sweden


swedtgc2 1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


A film was made of it as well.  Perhaps you heard of it.  Didn’t do particularly well commercially, I’m afraid, but at least the bear fight was stellar.


A little less well known was the stage play. It played in London and combined the three books into a single (long) show. You can see some of the effects from it here.


4thgradezero Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)
#44
Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing by Judy Blume (1972)

(#2)(#2)(#2)(#4)(#4)(#4)(#6)(# 6)(#6)(#6)(#6)(#7)(#7)(#7)(#8) (#9)(#10)(#10) – 92 points

Who doesn’t love poor Peter and his pesky brother Fudge? - Katy Ross

In thinking back about the history of my reading life, the first book I can remember really relating to is Judy Blume’s Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing. Here were characters that were in similar situations having similar reactions to those in my young life. Peter has an obnoxious little brother? No way! I have an obnoxious little brother! It’s the kid experience of "it’s funny because it’s true." - Amy (Media Macaroni)

Sibling rivalry at its best - Jennifer Hubert Swan, Little Red School House, New York, NY

The synopsis from the publisher reads, "Living with his little brother, Fudge, makes Peter Hatcher feel like a fourth grade nothing.  Whether Fudge is throwing a temper tantrum in a shoe store, smearing smashed potatoes on walls at Hamburger Heaven, or scribbling all over Peter’s homework, he’s never far from trouble. He’s a two-year-old terror who gets away with everything—and Peter’s had enough.  When Fudge walks off with Dribble, Peter’s pet turtle, it’s the last straw. Peter has put up with Fudge too long. How can he get his parents to pay attention to him for a change?"

According to American Writers for Children Since 1960: Fiction, the book came about when, "A house helper who knew that Blume was writing books for children brought her a clipping one day about a boy who swallowed a turtle. ‘Willie Mae,’ to whom the book is dedicated, kept Blume informed of developments, and the story found its way into the enormously popular Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing (1972), in which Peter Hatcher’s ‘problem’ is his two-year-old brother, Fudge . . . The original idea was for a picture book called ‘Peter, Fudge and Dribble.’ It was rejected as a picture book by Bradbury, but Ann Durrell, children’s editor of Dutton, suggested the form in which it was finally published."  And aren’t we glad she did?

Peter is a child everyman.  The straight man to Fudge.  Doomed to forever be overshadowed by his little brother (they don’t call this series the Peter Series, after all).

For a new perspective, I enjoyed this review of the book from the excelsior file.  Sort of brings up a point I hadn’t considered before:

"Peter has never mentioned wanting a dog, never really wanted anything but to have his brother not mess up his life, and all we see time and again are a pair of loving parents who don’t freak out (which is good) but can’t seem to reign in the terror of tiny town. And for all Peter has to put up with he’s given a puppy for companionship. After all he’s endured throughout the book Peter is essentially told ‘we love you, but we’ve got our hands full with your maniacal brother so here’s a puppy to give your the companionship we can’t give you’."

Twenty-two classrooms at Robert E. Clow Elementary School created cakes based on books.  All I can hope is that this one won.  There’s something delightfully twisted about it.


BSfB Tales 4th Grade No2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


And this was a poster created by Michael Orwick for the Oregon Children’s Theatre.  What I like about it is that it seems to get down perfectly the sheer devilishness of Fudge and the suffering his older brother has to endure. 


Orwick%20tales%20of%20a%20fourth%20grade%20nothing%20poster%20WEB Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Probably has something to do with the fact that Fudge’s face is lit from underneath.  The hair horns are a nice touch.

This first jacket was definitely the cover of the book I had growing up.


5834228348a071ca49813110.L. SL500 AA240  Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


ca319330dca0b563dcc05010l Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


YA911CD Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


tales Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


0142401013.01.LZZZZZZZ Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


41SQPXGK4JL. SL500 AA240  Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


n123600 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Tales%20of%20a%20fourth%20grade%20nothing Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


I’m pretty sure that this is Turkish.


9756663413 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


And there’s a good chance that this is from Israel.

 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Anyone’s guess.


spd 20090324210315 b Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Lest you fear that Ramona has all the fun, Fudge got his own television show too.  Right about 1995.



1340259166 b08ca221bb Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)#43 Ramona the Pest by Beverly Cleary (1968)
(#1)(#2)(#2)(#3)(#4)(#4)(#5)(# 6)(#7)(#7)(#7)(#7)(#7)(#8)(#8) (#8)(#9)(#10)(#10) – 94 points

Earliest strong, mischievous female character I can remember - Chris Vollmer, Librarian/ITL/Lit. First Coordinator, Browning School, Milwaukee, WI

In my own childhood, I loved Henry Huggins, his friend Beezus, and the rest,   but I think BC found her best voice in the character of Beezus’ little sister, Ramona. Ramona the Pest wasn’t published until I was in high school; but I later read the Ramona series to my kids and fell in love with her spunk and imagination. She is a real little girl who just leaps off the page! Bless BC for knowing and writing about such children. (I almost named my fourth child "Ramona," but I was afraid of how she might turn out!) - Lori Erokan

There is no other character that I identify more with than Ramona. Notice that I didn’t use the past tense of the verb? As a child I fully understood every motivation that Ramona had for the trouble she managed to find herself in, whether it was getting stuck in the mud because it was too irresistible to one sporting new boots, to being fascinated by the fancy girl’s ringlets to the point of covert tugging. Beverly Clearly is an absolute genius when it comes to capturing what it means to be a kid. She completely understands their fears, joys, anxieties, and passions. It took Ramona 50 years to go from being a casual mention as Beezus’s odd little sister in Henry Huggins to reach 4th grade in Ramona’s World. I figure I still have a few years before I need to outgrow my Ramona stage.  – DaNae (The Librariest)

“Sit here for the present.” - Sarah Flowers

In Anita Silvey’s 100 Best Books for Children, she says that "Critics have described Ramona the Pest as a girl’s experiences in meeting the Establishment." Which just makes me think that a book called Ramona Vs. The Man would have made perfect sense. Someday, sad to say, we’ll see someone take Ramona and turn her into a teenager. If they’ve any sense at all, they’ll make her one that wears combat boots.

Amazon described the plot as, "The engaging tale of young Ramona Quimby’s first days in kindergarten, Ramona the Pest takes a pint-sized perspective on the trials and delights of beginning school. Ramona can’t wait to learn all the important things. But she’s disappointed when her teacher can’t fill in missing parts of story lines, such as how Mike Mulligan (of Mike Mulligan and His Steam Shovel) went to the bathroom while digging the basement of the town hall. Nonetheless, Ramona loves her teacher, and loves going to school in spite of the torments–having to wear hand-me-down boots, for example, or having to (sometimes) suppress the urge to pull on another girl’s ‘boing-boing’ curls."

Of course Ramona had appeared for years in Cleary’s other books. Silvey says, "Cleary thought about Ramona the Pest for fifteen years before writing the book. In a New York taxi in 1953, her editor suggested that Cleary develop a story about Ramona, a minor character in the Henry Huggins books. She dismissed this idea and continued to work on other projects. But she found that Ramona, until then making only cameo appearances, began to take on a life of her own. So in 1968, Beverly Cleary picked up a sheet of paper and began with a title, Ramona the Pest. ‘The story of Ramona’s clash with the school system, her eagerness for attention, her stubbornness, her misunderstandings, her fears, her longing to love and be loved, almost seemed to write itself’."

  • Read some of the book here.
  • Collecting Children’s Books has always exceeded at posting fantastic April Fools posts.  The one about Ramona was one of the best.
  • Tattoos are cool, sure.  Tattoos of Ramona?  Extra cool.


There’s just something about Ramona that makes people want to sculpt her.  I mentioned during the Henry Huggins post (#66) that there was a Beverly Cleary Statue Garden in Portland where he and Ribsy reside.  Well, Ramona’s there as well. And boy does she look happy.

ramona Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

ramona plaque1248273546 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


This is hardly the only sculpture of Ramona in the world, though.  In the nearby Gresham Regional Library in Gresham, Oregon two Ramona busts by artist Lee Hunt reside.  The smiling one sports a quote from Ramona the Pest.

ramona1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

ramona2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


Across the country in St. Paul, Minnesota, two different Ramona busts live.  The artist?  Lee Hunt again!  Clearly Hunt decided to hit it big by just doing Ramona busts all the time.  The thing is, though one is happy and one is sad again, the happys are very different. 

ramona statue sm Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

ramona statue 2 sm Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


A critic in Young Readers’ Review commented: "As in all her books about the boys and girls of Klickitat Street, Mrs. Cleary invests [Ramona the Pest] with charm, humor, and complete honesty. There are some adults who can remember many incidents from their early childhood; there are few who can remember how they felt about things and why; there are fewer who can communicate these feelings. And fewer still who can retain the humorous aspects. Mrs. Cleary is one of those rare ones. . . . Even boys and girls who dislike stories about children younger than themselves enjoy the incidents in which Ramona makes a pest of herself. . . . Ramona has never been funnier and has never been so sympathetic a character. . . . As usual, this is standard Cleary first-rate entertainment."

And the New York Times said, “Ramona’s adventures ring as true as the recess bell.”

f905b340dca07ba76fd54010.L. SL500 AA240  Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


ramona pest Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


ramona150 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


ramonathepest Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

494291061 M Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


imageDB Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


lens6751062 1251739697LittleHouseOnThePrairie Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)
#42
Little House on the Prairie by Laura Ingalls Wilder (1935)(#2)(#2)(#2)(#3)(#3)(#4)(#4)(# 4)(#4)(#4)(#8)(#8)(#8)(#8)(#9) (#9)(#9) – 96 points

This was one book that spurred my love of reading. I read it so many times when I was a kid that I practically memorized it. (And I still quote passages of it to my children.) I wanted to be Laura. I wanted to enjoy life like Laura. I wanted to write like Laura. I’m glad I had Laura in my life. - Melissa Fox (Book Nut)

Yeah, I was Laura for more Halloweens than I can count.   Loved the strength of Pa, the adventure of the wagon ride, that moment when Jack’s green eyes show in the prairie dark and Laura fears he is a wolf.   I know people are worried about Ma’s racism and Laura’s wanting a papoose of her own.   It startles me again each time I read those bits – but they’ve offered a real opportunity for me to talk about these issues with my kids and I appreciate that.   They are books of their time. Linda Urban

My first understanding that less… an orange and a cornhusk doll for Christmas… can be more. - Michele Gawenka  

"The vast prairie was dark and still. Only the wind moved stealthily through the grass, and the large, low stars hung glittering from the sky. The campfire was cozy in the big dark stillness. …"

The synopsis from the publisher reads, "The adventures continue for Laura Ingalls and her family as they leave their little house in the Big Woods of Wisconsin and set out for Kansas. They travel for many days in their covered wagon until they find the best spot to build their little house on the prairie. Soon they are planting and plowing, hunting wild ducks and turkeys, and gathering grass for their cows. Sometimes pioneer life is hard, but Laura and her folks are always busy and happy in their new little house."

New York Times book critic Eden Ross Lipson mentioned in Everything I Need to Know I Learned from a Children’s Book by Anita Silvey that the book that affected her the most as a kid was this one.  Says Lipson, "This plain account focuses on ordinary lives, but that is why it is so thrilling and engrossing.  The family’s ordinary lives are so far from our own, unimaginably remote to today’s children.  But the lesson the books taught me, and still teach without comment, is that there is dignity, honor, and pleasure in work well done."

This is the Little House book that perhaps draws the most controversy in the series. In article "Little Squatter on the Osage Diminished Reserve: Reading Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Kansas Indians" (Great Plains Quarterly, Spring 2000), Fraces W. Kaye says of it, "I cannot honestly read Little House on the Prairie as anything other than apology for the ‘ethnic cleansing’ of the Great Plains. That her thought was unremarkable, perhaps even progressive, for the time in which she lived and wrote should not exempt her books from sending up red flags for contemporary critics who believe in diversity, multiculturalism, and human rights."  Debbie Reese of American Indians in Children’s Literature also offered up a two part critique of the book (here and here) that is well worth reading.

One racial element that doesn’t get a lot of discussion but is fairly fascinating is the appearance of Dr. Tan in this book. As Alison Wilson in Twentieth-Century American Western Writers: Third Series put it, "A serious health crisis threatens the entire family when they come down with the ‘ague’ (malaria). Fortunately, they are saved by a visit from a neighbor, Mrs. Scott, who brings Dr. Tan, a black physician, who prescribes a bitter powder–probably quinine–for them, then nurses them back to health. They had all been bitten many times by the swarms of mosquitoes that lived near the creek, but they do not connect the insects with their illness; in fact, Mrs. Scott is convinced it has come from eating watermelon!" For some reason Dr. Tan, whose role is quite small in the book, always struck me as the most interesting fellow in the story. Who was this guy? What was his life like? Where did he end up in the end?

Silvey mentions too that "When scholars go back to manuscripts of these books, it is clear that Wilder collaborated with her daughter Rose Wilder Lane, a ghostwriter by trade, to achieve a finished manuscript.  Although we may never know what one wrote and the other changed, these books stand as one of the greatest mother/daughter collaborations of all times."  So much so there is an upcoming work of poetry by Jeannie Atkins coming out called Borrowed Names: Poems About Laura Ingalls Wilder, Madam C.J. Walker, Marie Curie, and Their Daughters.  Keep an eye peeled for that one.

  • Read some of the book here.
  • It is also very interesting to note that Little House on the Prairie is not listed amongst the other titles by Laura Ingalls Wilder at Little House Books.

little house on the prairie Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

 1 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


n94736 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


And memorable indeed, the television show:


Jacket Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)
#41
The Witch of Blackbird Pond by Elizabeth George Speare (1958)
(#1)(#1)(#2)(#2)(#3)(#3)(#3)(# 3)(#4)(#5)(#7)(#7)(#8)(#8)(#8) (#9)(#10) – 103 points

I consider this Juvenile not YA-great historical fiction, hint of romance - Amy Sears, Supervising Librarian, Head of Youth Services, Teaneck Public Library, Teaneck, NJ

This is the first book I can remember where I was interested in the love story. I feared for the future of Kit’s relationship with Nat Eaton as much as I did for her safety.   - Kara Dean

School Library Journal described the plot as, "The setting is the Colony of Connecticut in 1687 amid the political and religious conflicts of that day. Sixteen-year-old Kit Tyler unexpectedly arrives at her aunt and uncle’s doorstep and is unprepared for the new world which awaits her. Having been raised by her grandfather in Barbados, she doesn’t understand the conflict between those loyal to the king and those who defend the Connecticut Charter. Unprepared for the religious intolerance and rigidity of the Puritan community, she is constantly astounding her aunt, uncle, and cousins with her dress, behavior, and ideas. She takes comfort in her secret friendship with the widow, Hannah Tupper, who has been expelled from Massachusetts because she is a Quaker and suspected of being a witch. When a deathly sickness strikes the village, first Hannah and then Kit are accused of being witches. Through these conflicts and experiences, Kit comes to know and accept herself. She learns not to make hasty judgments about people, and that there are always two sides to every conflict."

This was Speare’s second children’s novel. Silvey says that with this book, "After spending a year and a half working on the novel, Speare sent it to Mary Silva Cosgrave, the editor who had rescued her first book, Calico Captive, from a pile of unsolicited manuscripts. Cosgrave found the manuscript for The Witch of Blackbird Pond to be the most perfectly crafted she had ever seen. Because Speare had been so thorough in her research and in the way she had pieced the book together, Cosgrave suggested only one minor correction before the book went to press."

It won the Newbery, of course, beating out The Family Under The Bridge by Natalie Savage Carlson, Along Came A Dog by Meindert Dejong, Chucaro: Wild Pony of the Pampa by Francis Kalnay, and The Perilous Road by William O. Steele. But Silvey reports a shocking piece of news about that committee. "Although the details of the Newbery’s selection process usually remain confidential, the chair of the committee revealed that The Witch of Blackbird Pond won the Newbery Medal unanimously on the first ballot, an extremely rare event." No secrets that year, I see.

Of course Lizzie Skurnick had to have her say about the book over at Fine Lines.  A sample:

"What’s wonderful about Witch — and what distinguishes it, I think, from the American Girl novels I like to flog unmercifully because I don’t think novels should have branded stores with cafes that serve things like ‘American Girl Pasta’ — is that the narrative isn’t a flimsy cover for a history lesson, and neither is Kit a stand-in for heroic, spunky girls resisting the powers-that-be everywhere."

And I adore the covers.  Particularly the romance novely ones like this:


ddf4024128a0b23d3489d010.L Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


blackbird021508 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

witch of blackbird pond Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


0 440 49596 2 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

9780007148974 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

Witch%20of%20Blackbird%20Pond Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)

1094738669 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)


share save 171 16 Top 100 Childrens Novels (#45 41)
Elizabeth Bird About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently New York Public Library's Youth Materials Collections Specialist. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of NYPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. Z-Dad says:

    We love watching Fudge at our house. Hulu.com has all the episodes. Though, I made sure we read the books before the kids could watch it…

  2. David Ziegler says:

    Great group of characters highlighted in this group, and fun to see Fudge, Ramona and Laura side by side. One of my picks finally appears – Go Laura, and Pa, of course!

  3. Sarah Johnson says:

    I believe the one cover of Fourth Grade Nothing is in Thai. I’m not certain as I don’t read Thai.
    The characters appear the same as those in some Thai picture books I picked up at the Frankfurt Book Fair.

  4. Melissa (Book Nut) says:

    I think this is the first time I’ve actually read all the books! And I’m impressed with how much we love our Ramona. :-)

  5. Briar says:

    Ugh. I would have pulled Pullman up a bit more in the list if I had left him where I had him, in my 2nd or 3rd spot. I deemed it technically YA, getting too hung up on the later books, maybe. That was silly of me. Glad to see Blackbird Pond and Fourth Grade Nothing, as they were in my runners-up list, too.

  6. Marcie Atkins says:

    The Tales of the Fourth Grade Nothing that you were sure about is Thai. I grew in Thailand and am amazed at how several of the books you have featured have been translated into Thai. It was one of my favorites as a kid, but I read it in English. :)

  7. Marcie Atkins says:

    Sorry I goofed above. It SHOULD say, “the one that you weren’t sure about”. Sorry for the glaring typo.

  8. Amy says:

    I was thinking of Golden Compass as more YA, too. It should’ve been on my top 10, but at this point I want about 10 extra books squeeze into my top 10. Golden Compass can be number 3 1/2.

  9. Laurie (Six Boxes of Books) says:

    I am puzzled by the Little House comment about “an orange and a cornhusk doll.”

  10. Miriam says:

    Ooooh, the first appearance of one of my choices! (AND I get quoted! Squee!)

    Though I just yesterday remembered a book that really should have made my list and didn’t. Hopefully other people remembered it and it will have its rightful place.

    I never read Witch of Blackbird Pond, though all its descriptions sound like something I’d love… I think the cover (the Yearling Newbery one, fourth of the extra covers shown) always turned me off. Maybe now I’ll go read it.

  11. Sandy D. says:

    Wow – “The Golden Compass” covers are simply amazing.

    It’s a little sad how much the cover influences my 13 y.o. son’s choices of what to read – he took one look at my copy of “The Golden Compass” and said no thanks. But I know it is something he *would* like, if he gave it a try. I may see if the library copy is more attractive, and just leave it on the coffee table.

  12. Libby says:

    first of one of my choices here, too! I’m loving the reminders of all the books I didn’t nominate…

  13. Emily says:

    I was so sure the Golden Compass was YA I didn’t even think to check on Powells! Otherwise it would have been in my top three for sure. I’m glad to see my not voting for it hasn’t hurt its standing too much.

    Today list if full of things that I read and loved and completely forgot about when making my list (Witch of Blackbird Pond especially, but also Ramona and all the Little House books).

  14. My Boaz's Ruth says:

    Actually, Powell’s DOES classify Golden Compass as Young ADult, not Children’s..

  15. Miriam says:

    Okay, who are these mysterious people who like Harry Potter and hate His Dark Materials, or like His Dark Materials and hate Harry Potter? I have never met any of them! They’re very different, certainly, but I don’t think their audiences are very different. And I’ve certainly heard them subjected to similar critiques about series pacing, scale, and 11th hour visits from the Exposition Fairy. And unlike The Graveyard Book and Coraline, I know there are ballots that included both Golden Compass and something Harry.

  16. My Boaz's Ruth says:

    *raises hand* I like Harry Potter and really really didn’t like the Pullman series.

  17. TomAngleberger says:

    I trust there is more Ramona — and possibly more Fudge? — to come?

    Rather shocking to see them here in the 40s. The same with Little House. I would have thought any of these three a potential #1.

  18. Sharon says:

    *Sits behind My Boaz and raises hand as well* I adore Potter, and I stopped with Pullman after “The Golden Compass”. Personally, I found it very dull. At some point I will make an effort to continue/finish the series, but I’m not going to hold my breath.

    Ah, Fudge. I just recently re-read all the Fudge books for the first time since I was young, and I was struck by how vividly I remembered certain passages. Poor Dribble, obviously, but also the incident with the Picture Encyclopedia episode, the potatoes, everything. Ah, dear Fudge.

  19. Els Kushner says:

    Loved The Golden Compass, liked The Subtle Knife, hated that third one with the wheeled antelopes.

    Love this list and the daily new reminders of old favorites. Though there is a little “augh!” mixed in every time I see another title that I didn’t list and wanted to. The agony seems worse with this one than with the picture-book list. I wonder why that is? (or maybe the earlier agony has faded in retrospect.)

  20. Jana says:

    Once I started the audiobooks of The Golden Compass I got really into them. I could never get into them by reading them though. I raced through the audio versions and ended up buying the third book because I could read it faster than I could listen. But, I think more fondly about Harry and re-read those periodically, I doubt I will ever re-read this trilogy.

    I too thought Ramona the Pest would be higher, maybe that honor goes to Beezus and Ramona. And I am going to assume that more Judy Blume’s will show up later.

    Each day a new list comes up I start crossing books off my list that I assume won’t make it, so yesterday I was delighted to see The Penderwicks because I didn’t think that would make it!

  21. Fuse #8 says:

    Powell’s classifies The Golden Compass as both children’s and YA. So I figured it had a place on this list.

  22. KHazelrigg says:

    Laurie (Six Boxes of Books)– I think that statement will make sense to you if you substitute either parentheses or dashes for the elipses:

    “My first understanding that less (an orange and a cornhusk doll for Christmas) can be more.”

    Make sense now?

  23. Sondy says:

    I’m starting to fear for my other nine choices. Some probably fell off because some thought they were more YA. I’m glad BLACKBIRD POND made the list, even though I put it on my YA list instead. But I strongly suspect my favorite might be a lot of other people’s favorite and might even hit the #1 spot. It’s so much fun having the choices revealed! These are some truly great books!

  24. Kara Dean says:

    Oh finally! One of my faves made the list :)

    I, too, am surprised to see Little House on the Prairie so low in the countdown–I assumed it would be the default Wilder book and therefore place closer to the top. Still, it’s not the Wilder book I chose, so who am I to say?

    There have been so many books on this list that I considered YA and then didn’t vote for, and now I feel rather silly. But now that I’ve cracked the top 50, I expect to see some more faves soon…..

  25. Cathy R says:

    I also think of Witch at Blackbird Pond as more of a YA title. I was considering it, but left it off my list for that reason. Guess I should have checked to see how Powell’s classified it :)

  26. sh says:

    Raises hand: prefered Harry Potter to His Dark Materials.

    We were just talking about Ramona yesterday. I was looking at Leonard Marcus’ Funny Business and commenting on Beverly Cleary’s birth date. My colleague (who is young enough to be my daughter) said, Ramona isn’t that old is she? She doesn’t age which is the mark of a great book!

  27. Grier says:

    Betsy, is there a prize for the person who manages to avoid picking a single top 100 title? I think consistency should have its rewards, even if it’s a bit dubious.

  28. Miriam says:

    Thanks, My Ruth’s Boaz and sh! Now I virtually know some people in that camp. I still think the articles Betsy talks about are a bit silly.

  29. DaNae says:

    I’m so happy this list goes to 100. It was excruciating to be limited to 10. Seeing some of my other loves show up is like getting extra chocolate chips in my cookie. Seeing books I never would have chosen but are still most deserving, is like Arnold Vick’s appointment as Secretary of State in the final season of the West Wing. (I’ve been overdosing on Aaron Sorkin lately and that is the simile that came to mind. Apologies to the West Wing illiterates out there).

  30. DaNae says:

    And oh yeah Betsy, couldn’t you have managed to squeeze just a few more Golden Compass covers into the post?

  31. Rosten says:

    I’m with those who prefer Harry Potter to Golden Compass. I read GC once and didn’t like it enough to read the sequels, then when everyone was talking about it I read it again, and still didn’t like it enough to read the rest of the series.

    I will say, this is the first one on this list where it actually ticked me off to see it there. Even though our library has it in children’s, I firmly believe that it’s YA… more so than Stargirl, which I also think is YA, but could see possibly handing to a 6th grader.

  32. Jennifer in GA says:

    Okay, who are these mysterious people who like Harry Potter and hate His Dark Materials, or like His Dark Materials and hate Harry Potter? I have never met any of them!

    *raises hand*

    Love Harry, loathe Lyra. (Okay, not Lyra, per se, just the book.) I couldn’t even make it through The Golden Compass before I tossed it aside with a big, fat “Meh”. I even went and saw the movie in hopes that it would interest me enough to pick the books back up (and I already knew about the differences between the two). Nope. Still bored.

    You could also add in my two girls (ages 11 1/2 and 10) into the “Love Harry, dislike The Golden Compass” category.

  33. My Boaz's Ruth says:

    Rosten: I think a good part of the problem is that they aimed the movie at a younger age than the book — and that has confused other stuff since.

    I stand by this being a teen book.

  34. Miriam says:

    Alright, now raise your hand if you’re a Compass fan but not a Harry fan. (Yes, I’m stirring up trouble… sorry.)

    I think that like Harry, it’s one where the first book is kid’s but the later books skew older, and that colors our perception. I certainly see Golden Compass as kid’s; the way Lyra is looking for a family and her place in the world , the way she delights in things, the way she interacts with adults come across as preadolescent to me. I also first read (and loved) it at an age where I was reading kid’s books and adult sci-fi/fantasy, but wasn’t yet interested in the focus on personal exploration/emotional experience/romance aspects of YA, and that colors my personal classification. (Yes, adult genre stuff was more accessible to me as a at 10 than YA stuff was).

  35. Rosten says:

    I was rather surprised at how strong my immediate reaction was to seeing it on here. Apparently I’m becoming too emotionally invested in this list. :)

    I would agree that the later Harry Potters are YA as well, but I never actually got beyond Golden Compass, so I’m not sure how much more YA they get. It’s been a couple of years since I read it, and all I really remember is thinking that it was a decent book, but wondering why on earth we had it in the children’s section. I do wonder whether Powell’s changed the section they put it in when the movie came out, since initial reviews from Booklist and SLJ put it in YA, while PW said 10 and up.

    Apparently Golden Compass can’t help being controversial. :)

  36. Connie Rockman says:

    I do love both the Golden Compass and Harry, but I think the reason that a Harry title made it into my top ten and not the GC is that the GC is so much the first of a series. That dreadful ending – Yikes! – While each Harry book ends with the satisfactory finish of the school year and ‘back to the Dursley’s,’ even though there are dire and tragic events at the end of Books 4, 5, and 6.

    And I’ve been waiting a long time to say this … for all my fellow Prydain fanatics out there … please note that if we hadn’t split our vote between The Book of Three and The High King, our beloved Lloyd Alexander would be on this list at exactly the same spot as Philip Pullman … so far. Perhaps there are others who chose The Black Cauldron and will pull us, collectively, even higher. Still hoping ;-}

  37. Darsa (Threeboysandbooks) says:

    I am new to this blog (was forwarded the link for the #70 BETSY-TACY write-up, as I’m a huge fan), but I’m on the edge of my seat as Betsy unveils the list.

    It is especially fun to see favorite old friends (RAMONA THE PEST, TALES OF A FOURTH GRADE NOTHING, LITTLE HOUSE ON THE PRAIRIE) on here. I have read all three of those books with my sons within the last couple of months and they love them as much as I do.

    Maybe Laurie was puzzled because the corn husk doll (Susan?) is featured in LITTLE HOUSE IN THE BIG WOODS and not LITTLE HOUSE ON THE PRAIRIE? If I’m remembering correctly.

  38. Eric says:

    Speaking of fantasy series with devoted followers. Where is The Dark is Rising and Wizard of Earthsea? I’d guess the former will still get one book on the list (sad news for Grey King fans most likely) as for the latter I’m becoming very doubtful. Looks like Narnia will only get one book in as well. I have a strange feeling that The Hobbit is going to be left off the list but somehow Percy Jackson will sneak in b/c of the student vote. Really hoping i’m wrong about this.

    The morning reveals are become much more anxiety ridden as we get to the top 40, there are 25 or so that are certain shoe-ins and the remaining spots are shrinking very rapidly. Every day an underdog favorite doesn’t make the list it becomes less likely it’ll make the top 100 at all. Is it time to give up on Steig making an appearance? The thought of that makes me want to cry.

  39. Wendy says:

    Contrary to popular opinion, Laura and Mary never get oranges for Christmas (Almanzo and his siblings did, but it wasn’t a big deal for them), and there aren’t any cornhusk dolls in the series. There’s a cornCOB doll, but Laura gets a “real” doll for Christmas. Lots of people have false memories about the Little House books.

    No wonder Laurie was puzzled.

  40. Darsa (Threeboysandbooks) says:

    Ugh. I totally *meant* corn cob doll, not corn husk doll.

    It is funny, though, how one’s memory about a beloved book can feel so certain and be so wrong at the same time. I have a friend who INSISTS that Moms (Trixie Belden Mysteries) made Reddy’s dog food from… various disgusting innards, I guess, and yet I have no recollection of that at all. And, of course, one of us is wrong.

  41. Stephanie says:

    I think this is my favorite slice of the pie so far. Just to throw in a personal note I first read the entire His Dark Materials trilogy in the 4th grade. It was not too hard and I loved it. So I would definitely consider it Children’s.

  42. Melissa ZD says:

    *raises other hand* OK–I love Harry and I also love Dark Materials, but despite both being dual-world fantasies with orphan protagonists, I firmly believe they are apples and oranges…which is why I think so many of us have a strong preference for one over the other. It’s also why I never think to give someone DM when they want a read-alike for Harry, for instance. I don’t really have a point, except for wanting to raise my hand for both series!

  43. Hazel says:

    I am a HUGE Harry Potter fan, but the His Dark Materials books changed my life. I agree completely with Melissa –they are apples and oranges. They are trying to do very different things, imo, and are responding to different things in children’s lit.
    Just want to say a few words about why Pullman’s books had such an impact on me as a pre-teen. I was heartbroken, as a child, over what happens to Wendy at the end of Peter Pan –knowing that it meant I was going to change, and was going to lose something when I “grew up” or went through puberty. Where Peter Pan was about what is lost (and there IS something lost when you grow up, and it’s good to acknowledge it), Philip Pullman finally provided a full answer to that heartbreak. His take on growing up is more complex and more joyful than J.M. Barrie’s. The Amber Spyglass finally made it desirable, for me, to grow up, and it provided a fuller picture of what is lost and what is found. This was a huge deal for not-quite-kid-anymore me. (Pullman’s revision of the “fall” from innocence has such resonances at that age -something I think people tend not to mention when they talk about Pullman and “the church”. He is not only responding to biblical sources, to also to similar themes in children’s literature…

    (No wonder Compass is hard to categorize, because I think it is about that very divide between child and YA -relevant to both. I read Compass as a “kid” and by the time the other two came out, was slightly older and into YA. So I think I’d classify HDM as YA, but they ARE inhabiting that space inbetween…).

    *sorry for the essay –just wanted to add another perspective, as someone who read HDM growing up. Wondering if anyone else had a similar experience with it?*

    (I am enjoying this contest tremendously! Thanks!)

  44. Fuse #8 says:

    And I, Hazel, think that you are a genius for the Peter Pan/Amber Spyglass compare and contrast. Why have I never heard anyone bring that up before? You’re on to something here. Wow.

  45. Miriam says:

    Connie, I think there’s hope for another Prydain appearance yet. Though my bet is on Taran Wanderer rather than Black Cauldron.

  46. Connie Rockman says:

    Hazel, your ‘essay’ is so illuminating – thank you! And, Miriam, Taran Wanderer actually would have been my top choice for Prydain, but I was afraid I would split the Prydain vote even more by choosing it. I read the Prydain Chronicles while in library school in my late 20′s and Taran Wanderer was my favorite because I was so much into a quest for a profession and place in the world myself. My daughter – who had heard it read aloud as a child, along with the rest of the series – read it again as a teen and used Taran Wanderer as the basis of one of her college application essays, for the same reason.

    Isn’t it fascinating to see the effect of these wonderful books at different stages of our lives. I can’t quite imagine what HDM would have meant to me as a child or teen, so am fascinated to read Hazel’s take on it. Betsy, you have created such a splendid forum for us here!!!

  47. Katie A. says:

    I am kicking myself for not including the Golden Compass on my list! And I just re-read both the Fudge books and the Ramona books during the past couple of weeks, and I think if I’d done that before making my list, the two books listed here are the ones I’d have chosen. Strangely enough, though, I don’t remember them at all from reading them as a kid, though I know I did read them.

  48. RM1(SS) (ret) says:

    I loved the Harry Potter books (Azkaban being my favourite), but I agree with Els Kushner about the Pullmans – my interest went downhill with each sequel. And I agree that both series began as children’s books, but ended as YA.

    I know I’ve read this Ramona, and of course I read Blackbird Pond when I was reading my way through the Newbery winners.

    Still only three of my choices, with the highest at #66. Don’t think there’s a great deal of hope for the other seven….

  49. Mary Ann says:

    Why are the Fudge books the only Blume books I haven’t read? Must remedy situation immediately.
    Ah, Ramona. I loved her even she was just a cameo in the Henry books. When I had my own child, she was so much like Ramona at that age, I knew Cleary knew primary age kids. As much as I love all the Cleary books, if there is only going to only one on the list, I’m glad it was this one. (Yes, it was on my list!)

  50. ricka says:

    I raise, what seems to be, the only hand in the love GC, but not HP camp. It is a lonely world for such as I.

  51. Anne Ursu says:

    Hazel, I love love love your comment.

  52. Billy says:

    I love “The Witch of Blackbird Pond” and consider it one of the all-time beast historical novels. It is the perfect example of how you can add something like a mild romance in a children’s book and have it be relevant, not take over the story, and be of actual interest to its audience. Altogether, It’s solidly written and characterized, and an engrossing look at history while still a fascinating novel of character change. I’m very happy to see it here on this list.

  53. Leslie says:

    I’ve found this too late to contribute a top-10 list of my own, but I can at least solve a puzzle for Darsa, who wrote:
    “I have a friend who INSISTS that Moms (Trixie Belden Mysteries) made Reddy’s dog food from… various disgusting innards.” Your friend is right. It’s from The Mystery Off Glen Road. “The lungs and such, or ‘lights,’ as professional butchers called them, were boiled into a rich broth for mixing with dehydrated dog food – for Reddy!” It’s on p. 154 of the recent reissue of the book.

    I’m agreeing with quite a few of the choices, and disagreeing with others, and thinking that some (The Thief; Betsy-Tacy; yes, I am a member of both rabid fandoms) should be much nearer #1 than they are.

  54. Scrumptious says:

    I am getting super tense with anticipation! I can’t believe we’re exiting the 40s and still only one book from my list (Blue Dolphins) has turned up. And then there are all those other books that didn’t make my top 10 but that I am still really rooting for, as well!

    The GC vs HP discussion here is quite interesting and Hazel’s “essay” was fascinating. I loved GC passionately but the reason it didn’t make my list was that, because the ending was left as a cliffhanger to make way for the sequels, the declining quality of the sequels reflects back onto the first book for me. It’s an amazing book, but it doesn’t stand alone.

    I wish I had been able to read Amber Spyglass through your eyes, Hazel. I was crushingly disappointed by it (not to mention pretty confused) and I wish I could have experienced what you experienced with it!

  55. Carolynne Lathrop says:

    Dear Betsy,
    I didn’t vote, but Golden Compass would have been in my top 10. I loved seeing all the foreign book covers for The Golden Compass, but I have one quibble. The one you say is from Estonia is Dutch, and the one you say is Dutch is not. I don’t know Estonian, so I guess it could be–it looks possibly Danish, to me. But it is definitely not Dutch.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Rowling#39 When You Reach Me by Rebecca Stead#40 The Wonderful Wizard of Oz by L. Frank Baum#41 The Witch of Blackbird Pond by Elizabeth George Speare#42 Little House on the Prairie by Laura Ingalls Wilder#43 Ramona the [...]

  2. [...] Swan. Jennifer Hubert. (2010). [Review of the book Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing, by Judy Blume]. Top 100 Children’s Novels. Retrieved from http://blogs.slj.com/afuse8production/2010/02/24/top-100-childrens-novels-45-41/ [...]

  3. [...] Swan. Jennifer Hubert. (2010). [Review of the book Tales of a Fourth Grade Nothing, by Judy Blume]. Top 100 Children’s Novels. Retrieved from http://blogs.slj.com/afuse8production/2010/02/24/top-100-childrens-novels-45-41/ [...]