Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. Schmidt

OkayforNow 200x300 Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. SchmidtOkay for Now
By Gary D. Schmidt
Clarion Books (an imprint of Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)
$16.99
ISBN: 978-0-547-15260-8
Ages 10-14
On shelves April 18th

There are three kinds of literary sequels for kids out there. First, you have the sequel that is so intricately tied into the plot of the first book that not a page goes by that you don’t feel you’re missing something if you skipped Book #1. The second kind of sequel nods to the first book and brings up continual facts from it, but is a coherant story in its own right. The third kind of sequel makes mention of facts and/or people in the first book but if you read the story on your own you might not even be aware that there was previous book in the first place. Okay for Now by Gary D. Schmidt would be the third type of sequel, I think. Ostensibly a sequel to his Newbery Honor winning title The Wednesday Wars, the hero of Okay for Now, Doug Swieteck, was a bit part character in the first book, and now has come entirely into his own in the second. For fans of the first, you will enjoy the second. And for people who begin with the second, you won’t miss a thing really if you haven’t read the first. All you’ll know is that you have a great book on your hands. A great great book.

“You’re not always going to get everything you want, you know. That’s not what life is like.” It’s not like the librarian Mrs. Merriam needs to tell Doug that. If any kid is aware that life is not a bed of roses, it’s Doug. Stuck in a family with a dad that prefers talking with his fists to his mouth, a sweet but put upon mom, a brother in Vietnam, and another one at home making his little brother’s life a misery, it’s not like Doug’s ever had all that much that’s good in his life. When he and his family move to Marysville, New York (herein usually referred to as “stupid Marysville”) things start to change a little. Doug notices the amazing paintings of birds in an Audubon book on display in the public library. The boy is captivated by the birds, but soon it becomes clear that to raise money, the town has been selling off different pages in the book to collectors. Between wanting to preserve the book, learning to draw, solving some problems at school, the return of his brother from Vietnam, and maybe even falling in love, Doug’s life in “stupid” Marysville takes a turn. Whether it’s a turn for the better or a turn for the worse is up to him.

arctictern 200x300 Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. SchmidtIt’s such a relief sometimes to read a great writer for kids. Not a merely good writer, but a great writer. Mr. Schmidt is one of the few. You haven’t gotten even two pages into the story of this book before Doug tells you about his brother hitting him. He writes that he, “Pummeled me in places where the bruises wouldn’t show. A strategy that my . . . is none of your business.” Beautiful. Right there we know that not only is our narrator telling us his story, but he’s also hiding secrets along the way. In fact, throughout the book Doug will repeat ideas or thoughts or phrases that he’s been ruminating over, seemingly unaware that he’s working those same thoughts into the narrative. Doug isn’t so much an unreliable narrator to us as he is an unreliable narrator to himself.

Schmidt’s dialogue is also always on point and interesting, but of particular interest are his descriptions. When Doug and his mother enter a bus to greet someone there, Doug says of his mother that “Her blue coat was spread out, and it covered them both like wide wings…” Doug spends a great deal of time comparing the people he knows to the birds in Audubon’s paintings. This is one of those instances where he’s doing it entirely unconsciously. He wants his mother to be a bird. Just not necessarily to fly away.

puffins 300x228 Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. SchmidtThere’s a bit of wordplay at work regarding Doug’s brothers that I think is clever but actually had me quite confused for a portion of the book. We learn pretty early on that Doug has a brother in Vietnam who was a jerk before he left and we know he has a different older brother at home. There is one moment when we learn that the Vietnam brother’s name is Lucas, but for the most part it’s easy to get confused and assume that the brother at home is Lucas instead. After all, whenever Doug feels himself acting like a jerk he says he’s acting just like Lucas. When we finally meet Lucas, Doug’s constant references to “my brother” (which is to say, Christopher) disappear. The two brothers now have names and are becoming increasingly better people. Christopher, for the record, is the only person in the family strong enough to carry Lucas. One can’t help drawing some comparisons to St. Christopher and the burden that he carried as well. Knowing Mr. Schmidt, I suspect this is no coincidence.

One of the most remarkable things about Gary Schmidt’s writing for kids is that he allows his villains some complexity. It takes a certain kind of author to create an unlikable individual (not hard), display them in an honest way through a child’s perceptions (harder), and then somehow manage to, if not redeem that person, at least show that there’s another side to them in a way that a kid can believe (unbelievably difficult). Stock two-dimensional have their place in the world but a novel like Okay for Now works because each bad person has something about them that humanizes them (with the exception of one, and that’s only because we never really get to meet him). The crusty old librarian has a son in Vietnam who’s missing. Doug’s brothers have been dealing with their father far longer than Doug, and you can see the effect. The coach at school is still suffering from post-traumatic stress syndrome. Doug’s father even is lent a bit of redemption near the end, though whether or not the reader is willing to forgive him is up in the air (I, for one, don’t).

There is also an art to taking a subject that is primarily of interest to adult, and making that subject palatable to a child audience. Louis Sachar did a fairly good job of it in the bridge-centric The Cardturner. John Grisham failed on every level when he penned the self-explanatory Theodore Boone: Kid Lawyer. And Gary Schmidt set himself up for disaster when he brought up not only the subject of James Audubon’s paintings but info on how to play horseshoes as well. I say he set himself up for disaster, but disaster was not forthcoming. He failed to fail disastrously. Instead, he manages to pull both subjects off. The horseshoes because they are a game and all games, even those played by folks who look like they may have served their country during the Civil War, are still essentially fun (caveat: If someone writes a shuffleboard book for 10-year-olds I may be proven wrong about this). The Audubon factor is tricky partly because it requires kids to care about dead, drawn birds. They have a little help in that Henry Cole penned the very Audubon-centric younger chapter book title A Nest for Celeste not long ago and some young readers may pick up on the name. Still and all, Schmidt and his publisher made the ultimately clever decision to begin each chapter with a painting of a bird that will play a role in Doug’s life.

brownpelican 225x300 Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. SchmidtGenerally speaking, motivations and characters are consistent here. Some moments made me question Doug’s sanity, though. Here you have a kid who almost has a psychotic for a father. He knows this and he also knows that his father has his heart set on winning a trivia contest at the company picnic that year. So what does Doug do? He joins up with a nice old man throwing horseshoes and decides to give all the right answers himself. Now if you live with a psychotic then you have to live by the psychotic’s rules. Doug doesn’t, which works in the context of the story (A) because Doug is contrary by nature and (B) because in the end it turns out that the old man Doug befriended was probably the one person at the picnic who could deflect his father’s attention. Still, for a moment there I wanted to shake that kid and remind him of the danger he was placing himself into. On a related note, I found myself haunted for quite some time after reading about what Doug’s dad did to his own son years ago. It’s one of the darkest things I’ve ever read in a children’s novel, but not so much that it’s inappropriate for younger readers. I suspect primarily older folks like myself will find it as disturbing as I do. Still . . . . *shudder*

I’ve heard some note that the notion in the book that an unknown, untried girl getting a Broadway part without any prior acting experience is, at best, laughable. They are probably correct about this. I admit that the Broadway show portion of the book is far less interesting than some of the rest of it. It brings some nice closure for the characters but sometimes feels a bit odd when you consider things like the fact that the kids in the show can live in Marysville and just travel to New York City to perform on weekends. Still, while I as an adult didn’t quite buy it, it didn’t hurt the book for me.

To my mind Gary Schmidt presents worlds that are full of decent people and not so decent people who have reasons for their weirdnesses. Worlds that you either wish you lived in or believe you already live in. There’s nothing easy about this particular Schmidt story. At the same time, it’s incredibly readable and fun. I credit Doug’s voice. There’s much to be said about a hero who can be a complete and total “Lucas” at times and yet still appeal to you. This is historical fiction that surpasses the usual trappings of the genre to become universal. Definitely one of the best books of the year. Catch it and catch it quick.

On shelves April 18th.

Source: Galley sent from publisher for review.

Notes on the Cover: Now I’ve heard at least one person I know say they don’t like this cover, and personally I have to object.  Vehemently.  To my mind, this is a brilliant solution to an age old problem.  Mainly, how do you accurately convey a book on a jacket without pretending that the book is contemporary.  There is a perception that if a kid sees a child on a cover dressed in clothing that is less than entirely modern, they will eschew the book.  I have to assume that this is the reason we haven’t been seeing a lot of bellbottoms on the covers of books like Shooting the Moon or Kalaidescope Eyes or even Mr. Schmidt’s own Wednesday Wars, in spite of the fact that they take place during the Vietnam War.  Ditto big hair.  So this solution for Okay for Now is almost pitch perfect, even if it is cheating a little.  First off, everyone likes smiley faces.  The paper bag shown here even harkens back to Doug’s deliveries during the story.  The unraveling baseball references not only the disappearing, reappearing, disappearing ball Doug wins in the trivia contest, but also the number of stitches each ball contains (an important plot point).  As for the clothing on the kid seen here, white undershirts are eternal, and I don’t think a kid could walk onto the street in 1968 wearing those pants and those shoes and have to worry about getting beaten up.  The title is a bit unmemorable, but I think the cover makes up for it, and more to the point it’s appealing.  I wholly and entirely approve.

Favorite Line: “In the whole story of the world, bananas have never once been a special treat.”

Other Blog Reviews:

Other Reviews:

Video: Hear Gary Schmidt talk a bit about the book, explaining that it’s more of a companion book than a sequel.  He also owns cute cats.  So that’s a plus.

share save 171 16 Review of the Day: Okay for Now by Gary D. Schmidt
Elizabeth Bird About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently New York Public Library's Youth Materials Collections Specialist. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of NYPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. Michele says:

    Oh forget the cats…the dog was cuter! And I can’t wait to get my hands on this one!

  2. Kristin says:

    It’s a brilliant, breathtaking book. I agree that the Broadway element isn’t its most powerful, but the overall journey is amazing. And does it hurt that Schmidt is a fellow Michigander? I think not.

  3. Genevieve says:

    Cannot WAIT to read this. As in I may have to sit outside the bookstore door until they open on the 18th.

  4. Brenda Kahn says:

    I adored this book. It actually ruined reading for me for a few days in that I didn’t want to start anything else. This was partly b/c I didn’t want to leave Doug behind and partly b/c no other 2011 book will have a chance against it from here on out. Everything else I read will be measured against my love for this book.

    That is not to say that certain scenes toward the end did not niggle at my investment. By that time, I was well and truly on board. I loved Doug’s voice, his little verbal tics were so endearing. I adored Lil. I loved the juxtaposition of the two librarians. I laughed out loud when I first realized that my own assumptions about certain characters were challenged. Schmidt is a brilliant storyteller.

    And the insertion of the Audubon portraits at the beginning of chapters is genius. Do you happen to know if they will be in color? I found myself flipping back to several of them quite frequently. I may have to dust off my school library’s copy of Audubon birds and display it next to Okay for Now when it releases.

    brenda

  5. Alyson Whatcott says:

    Schmidt is one of my favorite authors. Also lives in Michigan!

  6. Allison says:

    I loved, loved, LOVED this book. I couldn’t decide whether I liked it better than The Wednesday Wars (which I also loved), but I think I might have! Your review really captures the feel of the book. Even though Wednesday Wars won a Newbery Honor, do you think this one will be a contender too? I hope so.

    • Elizabeth Bird says:

      I’d love to know if the plates will be in color in the final product too. My suspicion is that due to cost they will not. However, considering that this is the first major Newbery contender I’ve read this year (to answer your question, Allison) maybe HMH will spring for a little something extra in anticipation of future sales. Hard to say. Whatever the case, this book is going places. And I actually did enjoy it more than Wednesday Wars. For one thing, it sticks in the brain better.

  7. Callie Feyen says:

    I can’t wait to read this book. I had the pleasure of being in two of Mr. Schmidt’s classes while at Calvin. I believe he’d just come out with The Sin Eater, and I heard him talk about how the ending was going to be completely different then what it was. He is one of my favorite authors to read. I can’t decide whether I like Trouble, Wednesday Wars, or Lizzie Bright and the Buckminster Boy better.

  8. DogEar says:

    Also pegged this for a Newbery contender and I hope the illustration will be in color. I believe it will be a mistake not to have them in color.

    “My Most Excellent Year” also has a rather unbelievable Broadway ending, but like “Okay for Now” it didn’t detract from the book for me (and I suspect it won’t for kid readers either). Suspend disbelief! Great review.

  9. Greg Neri says:

    I LOVE Gary’s work, but what is that strange device he writes on?

    • Elizabeth Bird says:

      Most curious. It seems to produce letters directly to the paper rather than a screen. Kind of an instant printer sort of thing. Seems steampunky. I wonder if it might catch on?

  10. Just reviewed this book myself, then read yours. And laughed out loud about the potential for shuffle board related kids’ book. Never say never, but living in the Shuffleboard Capital of the World, I hope not.

    I also loved the book, maybe a tad less than Wednesday Wars.

    Now I think I’ll see what other books you are predicting for Newbery 2012!

  11. Colbinator says:

    This is a wonderful book full of amazing paintings from the Audubon Society that really make you think about how you look at them. I’ve never read the Wednesday Wars but this book has inspired me to do so.

  12. Sandy D. says:

    Huh. I just read this on my nook, and I suspect I missed out on the illustrations. It was still the best children’s book I’ve read this year.

  13. Kristen says:

    I LOVED this book (and will be extremely disappointed if it doesn’t win the Newbery!), but more than that, I just finished reading it to my 6th & 7th graders who absolutely loved it! It was pronounced to be the BEST BOOK EVER, and my 6th grade girls were fighting over who got to read it first when we were done.

  14. Carolyn Dooman says:

    My Dad died on October 4th, and he had one eye open (who knows if he could see anything) and I thought of the “terrified eye” of the arctic tern. I don’t often read books twice, but did with Okay for Now, and I cried both times. The thing that absolutely did me in was how Lucas, the brother from Vietnam, would light up when anyone called him ‘Coach Swieteck.’ As a librarian, I really appreciate Mr. Powell, who took Doug under his wing, and called him an artist for the first time. I laughed every single time I read, “Shrieking llike an insane woman who has been locked in an attic for a great many years.”

    I am perfectly ‘okay’ with the cover.. it works! I cannot forgive Doug’s father. Period.

    I loved the book – our copy is in YA, which would make it eligible for the Printz, but I think it is geared for younger readers, which would make it eligible for the Newbury.

    Carolyn

  15. Carolyn Dooman says:

    err… that should be “Shrieking like an insane woman.” Sheesh.

    Carolyn

  16. Doug Sweitek says:

    I am in the middle of reading this book i love it!!! :D

  17. Marsha Redd says:

    I am a huge fan of Gary’s writing. I loved Trouble and The Wednesday Wars, and I simply adore Okay for Now. I really hope it wins the Newbery.

  18. Alison Follos says:

    Reading Elizabeth Bird’s review of Okay for Now reminds me how essential it is to have great reviewers write about great books. When you find the ‘diamond’ book among the too many rough, it is a priceless gift to have it effectively represented. Bird does this w/Gary D. Schmidt’s work. With all the e-glut assumptions that “If you liked this, you may like…” it is a pleasure to be served an adroit, sensitive and aesthetic slice of like literature. I will share her memorable review so that readers who may have missed out on Okay for Now, will surely take pause and consider it.

  19. Marty says:

    this is now my favirte book and diary of a wimpy kid