Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesn’t.

I’ve become a bit of a board book connoisseur in my old age.  While my cohorts are reading speculative YA fiction and high end narrative nonfiction I’ve been getting up close and personal with books that have pages that can double as coasters.  Aside from realizing just how difficult the darn things are to write (darn hard, she said cleanly) I’ve noticed that board books just don’t get a lot of credit on the interwebs.  There are no board book blogs.  No board book Goodreads Groups.  No hashtags for #boardbooklove or #boardbookwarrior (there are hashtags for #bbforever but they have nothing to do with titles for tots).  With all this in mind, I think there’s room enough in the universe for a post about some of the board books we’ve seen this year so far and what they have in their favor.  Cause when you read something 500 times, you’re either going to go insane or you’ll internalize it to the point where it’s the most fascinating thing you’ve ever read.  In the latter (or is it former?) category:

BizzyBearOffWeGo 300x299 Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Bizzy Bear: Off We Go by Benji Davies – So here’s the deal with Bizzy Bear.  On the outset, I wasn’t impressed.  I got some of these books sent to me by Candlewick and give them this sort of cursory glance.  They star a bear.  He’s British (a fact you’ll notice in a couple of the driving scenes).  The most striking thing seemed to be that you could move things or lift things with these strangely sturdy little circle cut outs in various pictures.  So I brought some home for the small fry and didn’t think much of it.  Fast forward three months and I’m part of the unofficial Yanks for Bizzy Bear Fan Club.  I can even pinpoint where the change of heart occurred.  It all comes down to Bizzy Bear: Off We Go.  The plot, such as it is, concerns our titular bear as he hops a cab to a train to a plane to a vacation where he rounds out the story with a lovely lass he must have picked up mere moments after arriving (well played, bear).  I read this book quite a few times, impressed with its ability to stand up to a baby’s beating.  There must be some superior form of cardboard at work on this puppy since Bizzy take a licking and keeps on ticking.  But it really wasn’t until we got to an image of a roundabout that my mind was blown.

The set-up shows a little roundabout with traffic moving.  There are trees on the left and right sides of the roundabout and the traffic sort of disappears under them.  Turn a little wheel on the right and the traffic circles around the roundabout.  Simple, no?  I’m ashamed to say that it probably took me thirty-some readings of this book before I realized something strange. Normally when a baby book contains wheels that turn n’ such the characters appear rightside up and then upside down.  It’s a circle, after all.  Not so with Bizzy Bear.  By some miracle of modern construction there must be two separate wheels at work that make it so that the characters never appear upside down.  It has been all I could do to keep from tearing my child’s beloved book into shreds in order to figure out what the internal logistics where of something that many parents won’t even notice.  All the books in the series work (and, thanks to their poundability, are perfect for library collections) but this is the one that truly has my heart.  Head over to There’s a Book and you can see a video of some kids putting Bizzy Bear through his paces.

hippopposites Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Hippopposites by Janik Coat – I’ve written once before about the strange proliferation of French names in the American board book market.  When I received Hippopposites in the mail I wasn’t sure if Janik Coat was necessarily French as well.  So it was that I picked it up and started reading it to the small Bird.  It’s certainly fun with a rather blocky red hippo appearing as all kinds of opposites.  There are touch and feel elements included and it’s a nice big size.  However, it wasn’t until we got to a certain two-page spread that my husband called out from the other part of the apartment “Is that book French?”  You see at one point the hippo sits there, plain as all get out with the word “free”.  On the opposing page it is in a small cage and the word says “caged”.  It is, admittedly, a rather French concept.  Say this like Godard: “We are free . . . we are caged.”  Sure as shooting, Coat’s French.  The book is also the first I’ve seen to use a kind of burlap inside as one of the textures.  Mind you, not everything is an actual opposite.  The opposite of “front” isn’t “side” no matter how funny the visual image in the book might be.  You see?  That’s the kind of thing a person begins to notice after a while.

Moo 300x202 Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Moo by Matthew Van Fleet – Slowly but surely we are growing a Van Fleet arsenal.  A fleet of Fleets.  With their huge spines it’s only a matter of time before all books in our home are discarded in favor of the next Van Fleet title.  The latest book from the master of the touch-and-feel genre is Moo.  If you’ve seen his other animal-related titles then you’ll have a vague sense of this one.  Simple rhymes show various farm animals grouped by type. Pigs on one two-page spread, cows on another.  Because they’re photographs they’re excellent at showing what ducks or sheep or horses actually look like.  Ideally, you wouldn’t hand this to a baby.  An older kid will get a kick out of a lot of this but the small Bird is, curiously, far more interested in the parts you can make move than the touchable points.  The rhymes don’t always work (“stretch” rhymes with “peck”, “butt” with “up”, etc.) but that’s not the lure.  The photos are the lure and there’s this section where a guy is milking a cow and a cat is catching the spray that the baby likes fine but that I personally could watch for hours on end.  Awesome.

NoodleLovesBeach Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Noodle Loves the Beach by Marion Billet – Like Bizzy Bear, Noodle is a Noisy Crow import.  And like Bizzy, I wasn’t putting much stock into Noodle at first.  That is, before my 10-month-old decided that Noodle was clearly the long lost sister/brother she never knew (Noodle is apparently genderless, though I suppose the swim trunks are a kind of a giveaway) and that she would adore these books above all others.  The beach title in the series is amusing because it is at this point that Noodle, who pretty much loves anything you hand him/her, shows a marked preference for weird feeling foods.  This is one of those books that employs sticky technology.  We didn’t have this when I was a kid.  When I was a child if you wanted to feel something sticky you plunged your hand in a jar of jam and were content with that.  These days, though, things are getting sticky.  The Van Fleets (both Matthew and Mara) like to use it and Noodle’s a fan as well.  When you discover the “sticky peach” in this book you will be shocked to find that your fingers actually do stick fast to the darn thing.  Can’t say it’ll be too great for circulation (our personal peach at this point is certainly of the “fuzzy” variety by now, ew ew) but I’ll credit it with this much.  500 times I’ve read this thing and the darn peach is still sticky.

BabyLovesSpring Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Baby Loves Spring by Karen Katz – I’ve mentioned this before but insofar as I can tell if Karen Katz were to walk in my front door right now my baby would abandon me as her mother and embrace Ms. Katz as her true lifelong companion.  And why not?  The woman perfected the art of the lift-the-flap.  I’ve noticed that the small Bird has a marked preference for Katz books where you lift something and see a face in some way, but that doesn’t mean she doesn’t enjoy the new “Baby Loves” series coming out.  Baby Loves Spring shows the regular springlike things out there a baby might encounter.  I’ll have a devil of a time explaining to the offspring someday why frogs say “Ga-dunk” in The Noisy Counting book but say “Croak” in this one, but we’ll cross that bridge when we come to it.

PantoneColors 300x205 Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Pantone: Colors by Pantone – I guess SLJ had a good point when it said of this book that “while many of the names are interesting, some are confusing. ‘Lemon yellow,’ ‘daffodil yellow,’ etc., are fine, but ‘soap orange,’ ‘pillow purple,’ ‘apron blue,’ ‘Grandma gray,’ etc., seem just random.”  I see where they’re coming from but I’ve noticed that the color blue is the bane of the color-based board book.  Coming up with blue objects that don’t all use the word “blue” in their names is difficult.  You’re fine at first with your blue jays, blue birds, blue jeans, blueberries, and blue sky.  After that it starts to get difficult and weirdo color combos are called upon (that’s where you get things like “apron blue”).  This particular book is eye-catching and though I admit that it just looks like they took some shades from the color wheel, slapped ‘em on the pages and called it a day, they’re well done.  The size is nice and the pages easy to turn.

Trains Go by Steve Light – I’m not actually going to talk about this one since I plan on reviewing it.  Long story short, it’s amazing.  My favorite board book of this year so far.

AreYouACow Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Are You a Cow? by Sandra Boynton – Board books are nothing new to this woman and generally speaking she’s sort of a master of the form.  Even without baby faces or touch and feel elements (generally) her books have a way of capturing even a pre-toddler’s interest.  With the exception of Doggies I think we’ve worked our way through every Boynton and darned if she isn’t making more all the time.  Are You a Cow? continues to show off her newfound love for computer coloring, of which I do not approve.  It also contains an ending that sounds more like a greeting card than a Boynton book.  Granted the woman got her start with greeting cards, but it’s strange to me that she’d turn back to that format after all these years.  Better that you should read the also relatively recent Happy Hippo, Angry Duck.  Now there’s a book with class.

CradleMe 213x300 Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.Cradle Me by Debby Slier – Finally, a face book.  Star Bright Books has done a heckuva job with diversity in their board books lately.  Last year’s My Face Book was particularly well done, showing a child with down syndrome amongst all the other kids.  And Babies, Babies! by Debby Slier is unique because without making a big point about it, all the children in this book are African-American.  Cradle Me is one of the more interesting titles, featuring different tribes of Native American babies with their own distinct cradle boards.  One of these babies could be seen in the previously published board book Global Babies where she looked particularly grumpy.  She’s not much cheerier here and indeed most of the babies in the book seem kinda dour at first.  That’s probably a lot to do with how young they are.  The back of the book explains each tribe that each child is from, which was good.  More to the point, the small fry in my household is gaga over this book.  She’ll read it on her own if you hand it to her and that, as far as I’m concerned, is the mark of a good book.  Best of all, it has the Debbie Reese seal of approval.

share save 171 16 Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesnt.
Elizabeth Bird About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently New York Public Library's Youth Materials Collections Specialist. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of NYPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. rams says:

    Happy birthday, Fuse!

  2. Ed Spicer says:

    The fascination with board books is a sure sign you are getting older and younger at the same time–a most curious condition. I hope you are happy with that, especially today. Happy birthday! I am sure that our neglect of board books is related somehow to the general tendency to undervalue those who work with preschool children? Cheers to you today.

  3. Debbie Reese says:

    Hey! Cool to see CRADLE ME here! Thanks, Betsy. And if your readers are interested in more books like CRADLE ME, I’ve got a list at my site. Here’s the link:

    http://americanindiansinchildrensliterature.blogspot.com/2011/04/top-board-books-for-youngest-readers.html

  4. You’re so right. More people should blog about board books. I’ve thought about it myself but our board books are so shabby, they are the most borrowed books in our library. Our central library can’t send us enough!

  5. jacqueline says:

    When standard PBs get made into board books it’s interesting to see how they get pared down. We had the board book version of Dr. Seuss’s ABC book first and would argues that the rhythm/cadence of the board book’s text is superior to the original PB.

    • Elizabeth Bird says:

      Oh a post on board books that are more successful in BB form than their original picture book format is a post in and of itself! I’d add Orange Bear Apple Pear to such a list.

      Chris, is it weird that I’ve never read a board book of Goodnight Moon to my own offspring? I suspect this will need to be remedied. I thought about linking to this post on my wiki but I dunno. They’re not technically reviews though, so I may hold off.

      And Sondy, I can understand not wanting to be able to place holds on board books since they’re a devil to locate when they appear on the holds lists. But since I don’t really want to buy ‘em all and since I love the convenience of getting to take loads of them home, I’m awfully glad we can. Are they gross? Sure, but my baby’s essentially a walking pile of goo. C’est la vie, non?

  6. This is excellent. I need to order new board books, so this gives me some great titles. One of my favorite board book series is the Busy —- series by John Schindel. Busy bear cubs, busy pandas, busy birds, busy elephants, busy dogs, etc. Simple board books depicting animals at play (using photography). Our copies are constantly circulating.

  7. ChrisinNY says:

    Fine…..you couldn’t have written this 4 weeks ago before I sent off a batch of books* to my brand new great niece? I’ll try to bookmark it for future babies.

    *I did use the previous 100 Favorite Picture Book Poll to select the titles I sent: Goodnight Moon (in boardbook); Miss Rumphius; and The Library.

  8. ChrisinNY says:

    PS I hope you add these titles to your review links.

  9. Mary Gibson says:

    Thank you for your great review of “Cradle Me!” “Cradle Me” is flying off the shelves, our first printing of 8500 are almost gone! Reprinting now, expect delivery July. Look for “Cradle Me” soon at the Smithsonian gift stores in DC.

  10. lisainberlin says:

    Sticky parts, wheels with bears that never come up upside down…you make me curious! I wish you a very happy birthday!

  11. Sondy says:

    Our library system doesn’t even try to alphabetize board books, and you can’t put them on hold. This might be construed as a lack of respect for them, but it’s probably just that it’s easier to put them in a basket than a shelf, because of all the different sizes. Besides, with all the mouthing that goes on, I think board books are one type of book I prefer to purchase for a baby. And even though my own son is almost heading off to college, my little sister is now expecting a baby! So I will use this post for purchasing ideas! Thanks, Betsy! And Happy Birthday!

  12. Samantha says:

    As I love a good board book, I want to add two favorites. “Hippos Go Berserk” by Boynton is a hall of famer for us. It may be the number 1. It accompanied my son to parks, restaurants, across state lines, you name it. It has been close to 4 years since I’ve regularly read “Hippos” and I am confident that I can still recite most of it by heart. “One hippo, all alone, calls two hippos on the phone.” I still LOVE it’s rollicking rhythm. The other board book my son and I adored is a shortened version of a successful picture book: “One Hungry Monster” by Heyboer O’Keefe. Lynn Munsinger’s illustrations are fabulous and the rhyme and pace are wonderful. Both are counting books, but that’s not the only reason why we love them. When your daughter is older, don’t miss “Harry the Dirty Dog” by Zion in board book format. A very happy birthday, Betsy!

  13. ChrisinNY says:

    “In the great green room, there was a telephone, and a red balloon, and picture of the cow jumping over the moon”….It has to be at least a dozen years since I read it to L, but I can still recite much of it from memory. When she had a paper for a college child lit class, that had to pair with a read aloud, that was her “go to” book.

  14. ChrisinNY says:

    I actually think Goodnight Moon, while fine as a board book, is actually a little better for toddler and pre-readers, because of the cute details in the book (the scene darkening, the bowl full of mush being eaten, the time changing) and also the rhyming pairs that are great for the kids to do that whole prediction thing- first guessing, then knowing on repetition, what comes next.

  15. Genevieve says:

    ChrisinNY, I can still recite Goodnight Moon too (have done so when visiting toddlers).
    Betsy, happy birthday! What is your wiki about (books read to Baby Bird?) and could you post a link?

    • Elizabeth Bird says:

      Oh the wiki’s on the sidebar here under My Reviews Collected. Basically if you ever want to find a review of mine you can do so through the links there. Awful useful when I’m trying to remember what I’ve already done.

  16. Kate Wilson says:

    This is a really great post: as a publisher, writer and lover of board books (and user of them at home when my own children were little), I agree they don’t get enough coverage, and the skill that goes into them – words, images, scale, robustness – is considerable. It’s easy to chuck out any old board book, just as it’s easy to chuck out a haiku, but to create a good board book… well, that’s a kind of poetry. So thank you for this. One little point – the publisher’s Nosy Crow, and we are responsible for both the Bizzy Bear books and the Noodle books, both of which we publish via our good friends at Candlewick. For anyone who’s interested, there’s a Bizzy Bear app loosely based on Bizzy Bear: On the Farm out from us too and if you search the iTunes store for Nosy Crow, you’d find it.

  17. First of all, thank you so much Betsy for including There’s A Book in the Bizzy Bear review!

    My family is a huge fan of the books by Nosy Crow and I’m thrilled to see them getting this sort of recognition. What astounds me about both Bizzy Bear and especially the Noodle books is that they attract nearly every young reader they come in contact with. Like your daughter, my kids both have fallen head over heels for Noodle. In fact, I’ve recently been bringing the Noodle books to a toddler group at church and one little girl in particular will not calm down without Noodle. It’s a riot! Wonderful wonderful books and a fantastic article as usual.

  18. PS…Isn’t the sticky peach/toothpaste the best thing ever?! It really is still sticky after hundreds of reads.

  19. Sara O'Leary says:

    Great post – was just talking about board books yesterday and looking around to see what’s new. Here are a few of my old favourites:
    -The Zoe books by Barbara Reid because they are so colourful and lovely
    -Gumby and Pokey board books where you can pop out foam figures (no good for circulating!)
    -all of the Eric Carle’s but especially The Very Lonely FIrefly because of the way they light up at the end

  20. Children's Librarian says:

    Thank you for this, Betsy! I have the hardest time finding board books for my library’s collection because they usually aren’t reviewed by the big review journals, with the exception of Publisher’s Weekly. I also have a personal stake in purchasing them now because I have my own little one and now I understand the importance of board books in a way I never did before! We’re HUGE Sandra Boynton fans in my house because my son loves them. (Or as much as you can tell that a nine month old loves anything.) It seems that whenever I read him “Pajama Time” he pays attention, and if he’s upset, he calms down. That’s enough of a recommendation for me!

    I will be adding these to our collection!

  21. Lisa Von Drasek Practically Paradise says:

Trackbacks

  1. [...] more board book recommendations? I’d highly recommend reading Betsy’s post, Board Books 2012: What Works. What Doesn’t. I have no doubt you’ll find a great new board book for the little one in your [...]

  2. [...] board book baskets for them, I’m always struggling to find new titles that are just right. Betsy Bird pointed out that board books must be good “Cause when you read something 500 times, you’re [...]

  3. [...] offers a full review of one of the Bizzy Bear titles, plus some other board books, can be found at http://blogs.slj.com/afuse8production/2012/04/23/board-books-2012-what-works-what-do…. Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this. Tags Bizzy Bear, Board Books, [...]

Speak Your Mind

*