Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their Own

Excluding the very rare exceptions here and there, it’s fairly safe to say that when picture books are adapted into big screen movie sensations they are inevitably packed to the gills full of unnecessary awfulness.  Consider the fate of The Cat in the Hat if you doubt me at all.  Now there are exceptions to every rule, but for every Where the Wild Things Are there are twenty or so live action How the Grinch Stole Christmases to take their place (Seuss books are particularly egregious offenders in this way).

My philosophy is, if you can’t beat ‘em, join ‘em.  And as the mother of an almost two-year-old with an irrepressible appetite for picture book and easy book fare (not that there are any attempts at repressing being made) I’ve found that if a parent reads a book over and over enough that parent will start to construct elaborate subplots and backstories for the characters.  Here then are some backstories you could easily turn into full-length feature films.   If you had to, anyway.

AuntCameBack 295x300 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnMy Aunt Came Back by Pat Cummings – I see Will Smith producing this one, and I’m not even joking about this.  The plot, if you’re familiar with it, consists of a young girl’s recitation of the different things her aunt has given her after her worldwide trips.  Example: “My aunt came back from Timbuktu / She brought me back a wooden shoe.”  Read the book enough times, though, and one fact is crystal clear.  The aunt is an international spy.  Of course she is!  She’s going to Pakistan one day and Beijing the next and then leaving clues and pieces of evidence with her unsuspecting niece.  This interpretation gives a whole different feeling to the end of the book where the girl says gleefully, “But this time she’s taking me too”.  As a alibi, undoubtedly.  Clever aunt.  By the way, who’s a person gotta kill around here to get this board book back in print?  Seriously, the fact that I can’t order new copies of this for my library system is a crime against man.

AreYouMyMother1 211x300 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnAre You My Mother? by P.D. Eastman – Full credit to my brother-in-law for pointing out what this book is really about.  Have you guys noticed that dystopian and post-apocalyptic tales are everywhere?  Well, meet the original post-apocalyptic hellscape that serves as the backdrop to this tale.  A baby bird searches a scorched earth for his mother, encountering various still living reminders of a world that once was.  About the point you get to the abandoned (some might say burned out) car you get suspicious.  The only signs of human existence are a distant boat at the bottom of a cliff and the scary snort that never reveals itself to be anything but sentient metal.  In fact, that’s how I see the book.  The machines rebelled against man and war broke out.  The humans were all put down and now the world is ruled by diggers and cars and various forms of transportation.  They leave the animals in peace, but that’s because none of them have ever shown signs of intelligence.  That is  . . . until the birth of a singular baby bird!  Bum bum BUMMMMM.

GoDogGo1 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnGo, Dog, Go! by P.D. Eastman – If you can sit through futuristic P.D. Eastman then you can certainly sit through a glimpse into the world of Go, Dog, Go! that I would have missed had it not been (again) thanks to my brother-in-law.  The book consists of many dogs doing many things and they all appear, for the most part, to be male.  The exception lies in two dogs that have this strange little exchange throughout the book.  One will ask if her friend likes her hat.  He’ll bluntly say no and they’ll move on.  And this continues four or five times until, at last, at a wild party he tells her he likes her hat and she drives away in his car.  Not the greatest moral, but you begin to wonder what the nature of their relationship really is.  I see them as kind of the When Harry Met Sally of the easy book world.  But if she has any guts she’ll leave him cold and soon.  That boy’s no good, honey.  Worse, he has terrible taste in hats.

Mr.Croc  Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnReady, Steady, Go, Mr. Croc! by Jo Lodge – I don’t mind telling you that this British import with its enormously clever paper constructions was derailed for me (slightly) when my husband pointed that that Mr. Croc’s wolf friend Wilf had a name that sounded suspiciously similar to Wolf I’d Like to F***.  Wilf.  Yeah, ask me if I’m even capable of saying the poor guy’s name now without giggling.  And that’s before I noticed the sheer number of relationships going on in these books.  The Mr. Croc titles are probably where you can pinpoint my descent into madness.  Several of his books involve his friends, and I’ve started to construct these intricate relationship notes between characters.  Clearly Lulu the cheetah and Wilf have a thing for one another, but Lulu’s rich (she owns a plane and excels at tennis) and Wilf still works on a farm.  Can their love survive?  As for Elsie the elephant, I suspect that she’s been pining for Zebedee the zebra, but it’s all for naught at this point.  Moving on . . .

HopOnPop 219x300 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnHop on Pop by Dr. Seuss – Any Dr. Seuss book lends itself to interpretation.  That’s why we’ve such terrible movies of them out there.  Hop on Pop rivals Go, Dog, Go! in random chicanery, but there is one storyline in there that I’m particularly interested in.  That would be the saga of Mr. and Mrs. Brown.  Mr. Brown appears to be happily married to Mrs. Brown until one day in a chance accident involving a see-saw he’s flung out of town.  When he comes back he’s suddenly quite close to a mysterious Mr. Black.  Are they in love?  Is Mr. Black just his rabbi?  Pup’s not talking but Mrs. Brown is nowhere in sight.  What is going on here?

BizzyBear 300x294 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their OwnThe entire Bizzy Bear series by Benji Davies – Like the Mr. Croc series, Bizzy Bear is a British import that lends itself to WAY too many thoughts in my head.  Bizzy participates on a construction crew in one book and takes a vacation in another.  Nothing mind boggling.  I read quite a few of his books before I realized something.  Bizzy’s got a thing for pretty lady dogs.  In his pirate adventure, his firefighting outing, and his vacation Bizzy ends up in the company of a pretty dog, though it never appears to be the same dog twice.  The man knows what he likes, I’ll give him that much.

Now I’m off to go read some A.S. Byatt, because much more of this and you’ll start to see me mouthing off about the hidden meanings found in Knuffle Bunny.  Trust me when I say you do NOT want to be around for that.

 

share save 171 16 Reading Too Much Into It: When Simple Picture Book Plots Take on Lives of Their Own
Elizabeth Bird About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently New York Public Library's Youth Materials Collections Specialist. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of NYPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. marjorie says:

    I think I love your brother-in-law.

  2. Eliza says:

    I love the line you quoted in another blog entry when your brother-in-law said that Go, Dog, Go! teaches that guys will say anything to get a girl to leave the party with them. Cracked me up!

    Yes, why isn’t My Aunt Came Back available? This looks like the perfect book for us aspiring Auntie Mames out there. Now that I know about it, I want it. Betsy, please use your pull to get it back in print.

    Is it true that the Baby Bird is no longer a baby and is almost two? Surely not that much time has passed?!

    Fun and funny post. Thank you for bringing a laugh to my day.

  3. Amy Sears says:

    I so agree with you that it’s a crime that My Aunt Came Back is o.p. I really like that entire Growing Tree series, there’s also a great Aliki book in that series One Little Spoonfull that I use for baby storytime.

  4. Who would direct Fox in Socks?

  5. MM says:

    Oh, don’t even get me started about children’s books being made into films. I have friends who are animators, writers and voice actors in a lot of the films, and I’m constantly asking them, “Why did you do THAT to the story? Dear lord, why??”

    A few worked on “Epic,” which has no resemblance whatsoever to the picture book it’s “based on,” “The Leaf Men and the Brave Good Bugs.” (Trailer: http://youtu.be/WI3rlRHVrTQ)

    You can be sure any of the great picture books you’ve mentioned would be turned into movies whose only connection with the original stories was that the books were in the room with the screenwriters. For a few minutes.

    A book I enjoyed, “The True Meaning of Smekday,” is being made into “Happy Smekday!” I’m not hopeful.

  6. Ami says:

    Love it! I got sick of reading “Are You My Mother” a while ago, and changed the words completely so the baby bird is a zombie (look at his eyes!), and he is looking for brains, but the cat is already a zombie (eyes!!!), and everyone knows cows and chocolate labs don’t have brains to speak of.

  7. Curious omission of what I would’ve thought would be the obvious P.D. Eastman choice, “The Best Nest,” what with the “Mr. Bird” and “Mrs. Bird” and all… I think I’ve even spotted your husband wear that newsboy cap Mr. Bird is wearing…

    • Elizabeth Bird Elizabeth Bird says:

      Oh, fear not, James. We own that one. But so far my brother-in-law hasn’t conjured up any alternative narratives. What you see is what you get in the Bird household.

      Now I’m off to put a kerchief on my head and to berate my husband with a rolling pin in my fist, as per the aforementioned work.

Speak Your Mind

*