Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Burglars, Thieves, and a Classic Picture Book Trope

When reading a book like Mac Barnett & Christian Robinson’s Leo: A Ghost Story, one is immediately struck by the old-fashioned sensibility of the endeavor.  PW said that there was a “retro look of the art” and Kirkus went further saying, “Robinson creates a vintage 1950s-’60s feel.”  The feel extends beyond the art, however.  In many ways Barnett has conjured up a tale that relies heavily on a favorite trope of picture books.  Mainly, the ousted outsider attaining glory and love by catching a nasty thief in a home.

Screen Shot 2015-10-14 at 10.23.57 PM

I first noticed this trend when I read Leo and had an eerie sense of deja vu.  If you haven’t read the book yourself, allow me to summarize.  Leo is a ghost.  Ghosts are frightening to people.  He is lonely.  His only friend thinks he’s imaginary.  Then one night a burglar breaks into her home and he scares the miscreant with a sheet and traps him in a cupboard.  Sound familiar?  Allow me to introduce you to my friend Crictor.

CricktorThief

Crictor by Tomi Ungerer (1958) is actually a rather different case.  Unlike Leo he incurs only one moment of true fear at the beginning of his tale and proceeds to be petted and beloved for the rest of the book.  His capture of the thief is merely a plot point that allows him to be fawned upon by the larger populace at the end.  Note too how we say that Robinson has a classic feel, but Ungerer (who is now considered classic) was never afraid to include something like a sharp knife in the mix.  These days we don’t let our thieves carry weapons.

If Leo bears any similarities to a fellow sad sack protagonist then it’s Pinkerton.  Few would say that Steven Kellogg presented images more dangerous than Tomi Ungerer’s, but where Ungerer opted for a mere knife, Kellogg originally went for the firearms.  If you’ve ever seen Pinkerton, Behave (1979) on a banned books list, this old cover is the reason why:

PinkertonBehave1

Note the comment on the second image below:

PinkertonBehave2

In response to readers’ concerns and his own evolving feelings around gun violence, children’s author and illustrator Steven Kellogg and publishers will release an updated 35th anniversary edition of Pinkerton, Behave! in which the burglar depicted in this original book will not wield a gun.

In response to readers’ concerns and his own evolving feelings around gun violence, children’s author and illustrator Steven Kellogg and publishers will release an updated 35th anniversary edition of Pinkerton, Behave! in which the burglar depicted in this original book will not wield a gun.

PinkertonBehave4

There’s actually a rather lovely PW piece called Steven Kellogg on Why He Reworked a ‘Pinkerton’ Scene in Response to Sandy Hook.  You can see the before and after here:

PinkertonBehave5

Then there was Max the Flying Sausage Dog (2014) by Arthur Robins, a British title that I’ll confess I’m not as familiar with, though the trope shows up again:

MaxFlyingSausageThief

And I’m going to throw in Unicorn Thinks He’s Pretty Great (2014) by Bob Shea not because it really fits this theme (burglars in homes being stopped by the protagonist) but because I just like the sequence:

UnicornThieves

Far more along the Barnett’s storyline was The Incredible Painting of Felix Clousseau (1990) by Jon Agee .  If memory serves (and it’s been a while) Felix’s paintings come to life and eventually people dislike them.  Then one saves the day and sounds the alarm when a thief tries to steal the king’s crown.  Does that sound correct?  Help me out here, librarians.

IncrediblePaintingThief

That’s just a start.  I’m sure that there are more out there.

It’s very interesting to compare the look of the burglars over time.  Kellogg’s was originally and undoubtedly the most menacing, both in terms of personal appearance and actions.  Christian Robinson’s is far more of the gentleman thief, no weapon in evidence.  And yes, all burglars are depicted as white.  This is not something I think will change anytime soon.  Nor does it need to.  We can look for diversity in a lot of areas but it’s going to be quite a while before we seek it in depictions of crime for children.  QUITE a while.

So what can you do with this information?  Hello, instant storytime!  Back in the day Curious George Books and Toys actually did a burglar-centric storytime once, complete with mug shots and black domino masks.  Obviously you’d have to know your community to pull that one off (some folks might find burglars less than entirely appealing on a preschool level).  But you won’t lack for content, I’ll guarantee you that.

Share
About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. Ooh! I got one! Martha Speaks by Susan Meddaugh. Dog eats alphabet soup, speaks, foils robbery.

  2. Denis Markell says:

    One of our favorites was Dav Pilkey’s DOGBREATH which is the same plot (archetype?) about how the dog is shunned because of its halitosis until it catches the same burglar who seems to be in every book. Soon on its heels was WALTER THE FARTING DOG which was EXACTLY the same story but became massively popular (apparently becoming a movie and a plushie). Too bad Dav Pilkey got none of the notice. Whatever happened to him? I hope he landed on his feet.

  3. BERTIE WAS A WATCHDOG by Rick Walton. I don’t have a copy in front of me to double-check the story line, but from what I remember. . . Bertie is called “watch” dog because he’s the size of a watch. When burglars break in, they laugh at him for his size and wimpy-sounding bark. Somehow Bertie manages to scare them off. Dang! I wish I could remember. Gotta hit the library ASAP! Anyone out there remember the ending?

  4. DO YOU KNOW PIPPI LONGSTOCKING?, Astrid Lindgren and Ingrid Nyman (originally published 1947)

  5. No wonder burglars were my number one fear when I was a small child.

  6. Sarah Flowers says:

    The mice and Samson the cat in Graham Oakley’s The Church Mouse (“Ring the bells and summon help!”)

  7. Art Dog by Thacher Hurd (Dogs, art, Mona Woofa,, a Brushmobile-paintbrushes are flying!)

  8. I think Walter the Farting Dog fits this trope as well.

  9. candlepick says:

    Avocado Baby by John Burningham.

  10. Saara Itkonen says:

    Have you seen Burglar Bill by Janet and Allan Ahlberg? I remember reading it as a child but now it really seems so strange. A burglar steals a baby!

    • Elizabeth Bird says:

      That came up a lot when I was trying to find Google Images for this post. I love the Ahlbergs but wasn’t familiar with that particular book. I take it it’s British?

  11. Eric Carpenter says:

    William Steig’s Caleb and Kate has by far my favorite home robbery scene.

    also Burglar Bill is brilliant! Bill does steal a baby (accidentally) but in the end finds love when the baby’s mother turns out to also be a Burglar who left the baby unattended during a robbery. My students always love this book!

  12. The Ahlbergs also wrote a Christmas story: Cops and Robbers. (Robbers steal Christmas; cops foil them, led by the ‘Upstanding Officer Pugh. He can run like a hare and fight like a bear; and he’s good at crosswords too.’)

  13. How to Hide a Lion by Helen Stephens. The poor, misunderstood lion (who was only in the market for a new hat, mind you) has to hide between a couple of very familiar-looking stone lion statues to avoid inciting terror among town citizens, but ends up thwarting a would-be robbery by two thieves of the mayor’s candlesticks!