Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Holiday Books: There Can Be Only One (Part One)

I was tooling about the Twitter feeds yesterday, as one does, when I came across some folks promoting John Hendrix’s Miracle Man as an Easter book.  A great book, no question, though like most Christ stories (Jesus Christ Superstar, Godspell, and yes all my references are 1970s musicals, why?) it sorta leaves the resurrection for the last possible second of the tale.  Other folks would go the Easter Bunny route with Easter books anyway.  I know you’ve seen the statistics on how well bunny and baby chick picture books sell at this time of year.

And then I thought about some of my own favorite holiday books.  That’s when I came up with the challenge.

List some of the major American holidays and give each one a single book that represents that holiday best to you.

Results?  Eclectic. To say the least.  Here’s the first part of my very personal list:

Three Kings Day

The Storyteller’s Candle = La Velita de los Cuentos by Lucía González, ill. Lulu Delacre = La Velita de los Cuentos

StorytellersCandle

Thought I’d begin with New Year’s Eve, dincha?  Nope. Technically that would be the last holiday of the year.  I’d much rather kick a year off with Three Kings Day anyway.  And no, it didn’t tend to lend itself to a lot of checkouts in the library, but that won’t stop me from promoting this 2008 title.  Celebrating Pura Belpre and all she did for the children of NYC, this beautiful book is still in print, so you’ve no excuse for not adding it to your collection.

Martin Luther King Jr. Day

Martin’s Big Words by Doreen Rappaport, ill. Bryan Collier

MartinsBigWords

But which of the books about him would you choose?  In this particular case, I go with what I know.  I like more recent King books, sure, but there’s something about Collier’s work on this book that remains top of the charts in my book.

Groundhog Day

Brownie Groundhog and the February Fox by Susan Blackaby, ill. Carmen Segovia

BrownieGroundhog

Initially I was going to go with Groundhog’s Runaway Shadow by David Biedrzycki (last mentioned in my Transcendent Holiday Books of 2016 list at the end of last year).  Then I remembered this little delight.  It’s a trickster story as well as a Groundhog Day title.  No contest.  This is the one I love best in the world.

Mardi Gras

On Mardi Gras Day by Fatima Shaik, ill. Floyd Cooper.

OnMardiGras

Back in 1999, School Library Journal called this book, “An especially appealing book that offers children vicarious enjoyment of this special day.”  I’m just loving it for Floyd Cooper’s work.  This list today would not be complete without at least one Floyd Cooper title on it.

Valentine’s Day

Mouse and Mole, Secret Valentine by Herbert Wong Yee

MouseMoleValentine

I once met Mr. Yee in a Detroit bookstore and a nicer fellow you couldn’t hope to meet.  At the time this, the final Mouse and Mole book in the series, had just come out so I read it.  It was a mistake.  Not to read the book, but to read it out of order.  If read properly from the start to the finish, you really get a sense of Mouse and Mole’s relationship blossoming.  So few easy reader series end with the two main characters falling in love.  This is one of the few and it’s beautifully done.

Chinese New Year

The Year of the Dog by Grace Lin

YearDog

There is a curse on my head.  Apparently, whenever I am on a plane stuck on the tarmac, near dinnertime, with no food in sight, the only book in my possession will be a Grace Lin novel filled to the brim with delicious descriptions of food.  The first time this happened was with The Year of the Dog, a book that remains one of my favorite Lin titles of all time, and undoubtedly THE greatest Chinese New Year book to date.

Presidents Day

So You Want to Be President? by Judith St. George, ill. David Small

SoWantPresident

To be clear, I don’t think it’s the most brilliant Caldecott winner out there, and I think Mr. Small should have won for his other books a hundred times over.  That said, it’s a pitch perfect Presidents Day book from tip to toe.  Interesting Side Note: This is one of those Caldecott winners significantly changed since its initial publication.  Other past Award winners have changed their texts to be less offensive to 21st century readers but this book took it one step farther to include all new illustrations (Barack Obama is seen entering at the end).

Purim

The Purim Chicken by Margery Cuyler, ill. Puy Pinillos

PurimChicken

The title. Need I say more?

St. Patrick’s Day

The Wicked Wicked Ladies in the Haunted House by Mary Chase, ill. Peter Sis

WickedLadiesHouse

Nope. I haven’t gotten my holidays all mixed together.  When this book was read to me in 4th grade (under its previous name, “The Wicked Pigeon Ladies in the Garden”) I was enthralled.  The tone.  The content.  It was maybe the creepiest thing I’d ever encountered. It was originally published in 1968.  So why is it here under St. Patrick’s Day?  Well, the prickly heroine of the book joins forces with an old leprechaun.  Yes, that’s a stretch, but I say it counts for the holiday (plus I loved the book).

April Fools’ Day

PICKLE : The (Formerly) Anonymous Prank Club of Fountain Point Middle School by Kim Baker, ill. by Tim Probert.

Pickle1

Pranking middle grade novels aren’t anything too new these days, but I was always very fond of Ms. Baker’s debut.  This book goes above and beyond April Fool’s Day alone.  The kids are personable, the goal attainable (almost), and I just kinda loved it.

Passover

The Longest Night : A Passover Story by Laurel Snyder, ill. by Catia Chien.

LongestNight
I remember when this was released and the reviewers and critics went positively gaga over it en masse.  The art is gorgeous and as SLJ said, “the emotional angle makes it a great supplement to other more straightforward tellings.”  Sounds like a winner to me.

Easter

The Country Bunny and the Little Golden Shoes by Laurel Snyder, ill. Marjorie Flack

CountryBunnyGoldenShoes

Honestly, it’s almost too hard to choose. There are so many Easter books out there in a given year.  But I’m partial to this one. It’s hard to compete with the classics.

That’s the fist batch!  Stay tuned tomorrow for Batch #2.  In the meantime, what are your favorites?

 

 

Share
About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.

Comments

  1. Brooke Shirts says:

    My choice for St. Patrick’s Day is Lloyd Alexander’s “The House Gobbaleen.” It’s a perfect trickster tale, even if it takes a bit of a while to read out loud.

    In fact, there are many long-form picture books about the Good Folk that I like to save for St. Patrick’s. I also love Joy Cowley’s “The Wishing of Biddy Malone,” and while Eleanor Farjeon’s “Elsie Piddock Skips in Her Sleep” doesn’t take place in Ireland, its jump-roping fairies are the BEST and my kids ask for it every year.

  2. For Passover, the clear winner is The Carp in the Bathtub by Barbara Cohen. To head into the later part of the year: For Sukkot (no less of an American holiday than Purim), David Adler’s The House on the Roof, with Patricia Polacco’s Tikvah Means Hope in 2nd place. For Thanksgiving, Molly’s Pilgrim, also by Barbara Cohen. Rivka’s (or is it Rifka’s) First Thanksgiving is a nice runner-up, as is Duck for Turkey Day. For Hanukkah, perhaps Oscar’s Eight Blessings. I like Elija’s Angel for Hanukkah and Christmas, although it has parts that are a little dark.

    And, not a book, but the old Sesame Street special, Christmas Eve on Sesame Street is fantastic. I can still sing the songs and I still watch it some years, with or without my kids. It features ice skating and the nyc subway.

    In general, I think good holiday books are really hard to find.

  3. At my school, Hanukkah HAS to be HERSHEL AND THE HANUKKAH GOBLINS. It has never been surpassed. Younger children are very fond of the HANUKKAH MICE book. I love Eileen Spinelli’s SOMEBODY LOVES YOU, MR HATCH for Valentine’s day. It’s full of love without being mooshy, and when Mr. Hatch discovers that the Valentine candy wasn’t meant for him after all, there is often a gasp of pure sorrow. Older children like THE FEARSOME INN for Passover.

    I think Thanksgiving is a bit hopeless. It doesn’t have any supernatural punch. THE WIDOW’S BROOM is dandy for Halloween–younger children fight over THE HAUNTED HAMBURGER, which I think is–most disastrously–out of print.

  4. For Christmas, Geraldine McCaughrean’s WENCESLAS. The art postively glows, as does the legend.

  5. For Passover, I have two favorites: The Passover Lamb by Linda Elovitz Marshall–Jewish rural life is rarely depicted, so this is quite special and sweet. Also love The Little Red Hen and the Passover Matzah by Leslie Kimmelman–I don’t care for revampings of The Little Red Hen, but it works here with the message of opening the Passover table to all.

    For Easter–Here Comes the Easter Cat by Deborah Underwood is a great one for older kids who don’t want cuddly cute bunny stories.

    For Presidents Day….Bad Kitty for President by Nick Bruel is hilarious–one of my favorite Bad Kitty books.

  6. Benjamin Collinsworth says:

    The only St. Patrick’s Day book in my family is Paddy’s Pot of Gold by Dick King-Smith. My mom would bring it out at the beginning of March and read it to us a little bit each night until the 17th. I don’t think there’s been a new edition for a while.