Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
Battle of the Books

So How Did the BoB Contenders Do With ALA’s Youth Media Awards?

commentator1 So How Did the BoB Contenders Do With ALAs Youth Media Awards?

In case you’re wondering, BOB contenders fared pretty well at the YMAs.  I’m sure some of you think we may have had the inside track on the Newbery with Roxanne being on the committee and all, but I can assure you that was not the case.

BOMB . . . This title now becomes the most decorated book of the year with the Sibert Medal, Nonfiction Award, and Newbery Honor in addition to being a National Book Award finalist.

CODE NAME VERITY . . . This one got a Printz Honor.  Many were surprised that it didn’t win the Award outright, but SERAPHINA and THE FAULT IN OUR STARS which both also got six starred reviews were shut out of the Printz line-up entirely.

THE FAULT IN OUR STARS . . . This one got the Odyssey Award.  Not the award most people were predicting for this book, but it gets a second chance here.

MOONBIRD and TITANIC . . . This pair joined BOMB in being recognized by both the Sibert and Nonfiction committees.

NO CRYSTAL STAIR . . . I had it penciled in as the Coretta Scott King Award, but an Honor is almost quite as good–and it did win the Boston Globe-Horn Book Award.

THE ONE AND ONLY IVAN . . . Can this one escape the dreaded Newbery curse here at BOB?

SERAPHINA . . . I think this is the strongest book to ever win the Morris Award–and I thought there was a legitimate chance to repeat the Morris/Printz win of WHERE THINGS COME BACK.

SPLENDORS AND GLOOMS and THREE TIMES LUCKY . . . This pair of Newbery Honor books play to specific audiences–and if the judges happen to be fans of these books–either one could go quite far.

The following BOB contenders got no YMA love bombs: ENDANGERED, LIAR & SPY, WONDER, STARRY RIVER OF THE SKY, TEMPLE GRANDIN, and JEPP, WHO DEFIED THE STARS.  But maybe they should have?

–Commentator Jonathan Hunt

 

Comments

  1. I thought Seraphina was going to Morris/Printz too! It was one of my highest hopes (after Splendors and Gloom getting some Newbery rec and seeing One and Only Ivan honor. Messed those up but not too bad!)

  2. ElleLibrarian says:

    I think you may spur some into naming the Newbery book as their chosen Undead nominee . . . but I hope that Ivan breaks the Newbery curse all on its own!

  3. DaNae says:

    I was shocked, shocked I say, not to see VERITY get the Printz, but not so much to see TFIOS shut out. I do think Green’s book lives up to the hype, but there was an awful lot of hype to burden the committee. YA books barely bleep on my radar so I know little about the others.

    Looking at the list I thought I could be objective about my choice for BoB, but after a third reading of VERITY I’m diving in with blind,silly devotion to those two girls. I still have TITANIC to read but I’m aiming my tail gunners at her bow will hardly shed a tear when she sinks to her icy depths – although I’m sure Maddie will shed many.

Speak Your Mind

*