Comments on: The Best and Worst of Newbery-Caldecott http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/ A School Library Journal Blog Sun, 05 Aug 2012 22:26:42 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4.1 By: szwlx http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-740 szwlx Fri, 05 Dec 2008 18:39:30 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-740 hello, good site. hello, good site.

]]> By: Jonathan http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-741 Jonathan Sun, 13 Jul 2008 08:37:54 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-741 I think it was a good speech with a great delivery, but her comments on nonfiction touched a nerve with me as well. I think it was a good speech with a great delivery, but her comments on nonfiction touched a nerve with me as well.

]]> By: Susanna Reich http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-742 Susanna Reich Fri, 11 Jul 2008 08:35:37 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-742 I agree, both speeches were dazzling. But my jaw dropped when Laura Amy Schlitz made the comment that "we librarians secretly prefer fiction." If she had spoken only of her own preference, as she does in the recorded version of her speech, it wouldn't have been so bad. She's entitled to her opinion. But to speak on behalf of all librarians, as if that prejudice is acceptable, is dismaying. Yes, "dramatic narrative creates meaning" and "stories enlarge our lives," but since when does fiction hold a monopoly on dramatic narrative and story? As the author of an excellent biography of Heinrich Schliemann, Schlitz certainly knows this. I bet she could tell an enthralling nonfiction story about having moles removed if she wanted to. I agree, both speeches were dazzling. But my jaw dropped when Laura Amy Schlitz made the comment that “we librarians secretly prefer fiction.” If she had spoken only of her own preference, as she does in the recorded version of her speech, it wouldn’t have been so bad. She’s entitled to her opinion. But to speak on behalf of all librarians, as if that prejudice is acceptable, is dismaying.

Yes, “dramatic narrative creates meaning” and “stories enlarge our lives,” but since when does fiction hold a monopoly on dramatic narrative and story? As the author of an excellent biography of Heinrich Schliemann, Schlitz certainly knows this. I bet she could tell an enthralling nonfiction story about having moles removed if she wanted to.

]]> By: Jody http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-743 Jody Thu, 10 Jul 2008 13:50:45 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-743 My mother, Josephine Carr, once a member of the Newbury Committee (the year they chose SARAH, PLAIN & TALL)wrote a non-fiction book, published by the ALA called BEYOND FACT. She collected essays, and wrote introductions for each, on how non-fiction can be as creative, and full of vibrant story-telling, as fiction. Hard to believe we're still fighting this battle! JosephineCarrWrites.blogspot.com www.josephinecarr.com My mother, Josephine Carr, once a member of the Newbury Committee (the year they chose
SARAH, PLAIN & TALL)wrote a non-fiction book, published by the ALA called BEYOND FACT. She collected essays, and wrote introductions for each, on how non-fiction can be as creative, and full of vibrant story-telling, as fiction. Hard to believe we’re still fighting this battle!
JosephineCarrWrites.blogspot.com
http://www.josephinecarr.com

]]> By: Roxanne Feldman http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-744 Roxanne Feldman Fri, 04 Jul 2008 16:09:15 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-744 It was a slight "cringing" moment in the whole beautifully constructed and artfully delivered speech, for sure. And, it made me wonder (although I am definitely not denying my personal alliances of current reading taste with Schlitz) whether "facts" are not as fascinating, and some times more fascinating, to the young people we collaboratively serve in our various professions. If they aren't, then how can we explain the perennial popularity of books like the Guinness Book of World Records, the Baseball Stats books, and the DK Eyewitness titles? I, for one, as a young (from probably age 7 to middle school) reader, treasured a set of books called One Hundred Thousand "Whys" (it's a set of Chinese books on random scientific facts about animals, human body, the space, physics, etc.) I know there was not a "story" in each listed fact, but collectively, they became part of a bigger story for me, the reader -- it's a story of the world I lived in, a story that I was part of, and I made all the connections and saw all the connections between those facts and the "life stories" around me. And, many of such facts also presented themselves IN story books, as well. It was a slight “cringing” moment in the whole beautifully constructed and artfully delivered speech, for sure. And, it made me wonder (although I am definitely not denying my personal alliances of current reading taste with Schlitz) whether “facts” are not as fascinating, and some times more fascinating, to the young people we collaboratively serve in our various professions. If they aren’t, then how can we explain the perennial popularity of books like the Guinness Book of World Records, the Baseball Stats books, and the DK Eyewitness titles? I, for one, as a young (from probably age 7 to middle school) reader, treasured a set of books called One Hundred Thousand “Whys” (it’s a set of Chinese books on random scientific facts about animals, human body, the space, physics, etc.) I know there was not a “story” in each listed fact, but collectively, they became part of a bigger story for me, the reader — it’s a story of the world I lived in, a story that I was part of, and I made all the connections and saw all the connections between those facts and the “life stories” around me. And, many of such facts also presented themselves IN story books, as well.

]]> By: Julie Larios http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-745 Julie Larios Thu, 03 Jul 2008 00:25:03 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-745 As much as I enjoyed the speeches, I also was startled by the comment about non-fiction, so much so that I stopped listening for a minute and tried to get my head around what she possibly could have meant. Certainly, I grew up reading non-fiction, falling into it just as deeply (or more deeply) than any fiction I read as a child! There are so many wonderful examples out there of non-fiction books that are compelling, that move and change us, that leave us eager to turn the next page, and that make "meaning" in our lives. And all it would have taken to change the comment around was for a small qualifier to be added, "To me, it seems that...." That way, she admits to her own preference for fiction, but doesn't try to speak for the crowd. A strange blip in an otherwise fascinating speech. As much as I enjoyed the speeches, I also was startled by the comment about non-fiction, so much so that I stopped listening for a minute and tried to get my head around what she possibly could have meant. Certainly, I grew up reading non-fiction, falling into it just as deeply (or more deeply) than any fiction I read as a child! There are so many wonderful examples out there of non-fiction books that are compelling, that move and change us, that leave us eager to turn the next page, and that make “meaning” in our lives. And all it would have taken to change the comment around was for a small qualifier to be added, “To me, it seems that….” That way, she admits to her own preference for fiction, but doesn’t try to speak for the crowd. A strange blip in an otherwise fascinating speech.

]]> By: Kathleen Krull http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-746 Kathleen Krull Wed, 02 Jul 2008 14:42:22 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-746 I nearly jumped out of my seat when she said this. A gaffe, indeed-- a low blow coming out of nowhere in the middle of an otherwise enchanting speech. I was going to blog about this myself, but I'm trying to take a summer vacation from html. In any case, you said it all - thank you. I nearly jumped out of my seat when she said this. A gaffe, indeed– a low blow coming out of nowhere in the middle of an otherwise enchanting speech. I was going to blog about this myself, but I’m trying to take a summer vacation from html. In any case, you said it all – thank you.

]]> By: Judy Freeman http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-747 Judy Freeman Wed, 02 Jul 2008 14:13:05 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-747 This year's N-C dinner had the most visually compelling speeches ever--and why both speeches weren't filmed for YouTube, I don't know. (If they were filmed, they need to be made available for the whole world to see. I teach storytelling at Pratt Institute, and I'd love for my students to see Laura Amy Schlitz as a model of great storytelling and delivery. It was amazing watching her hold that audience. Gave me goosebumps.) It's not enough just to read or hear those speeches--and nowadays, it can't be too hard to film. People who couldn't attend would have the You-Are-There experience, and I'll bet it would bring lots more folks to the conference and the dinner in the future. This year’s N-C dinner had the most visually compelling speeches ever–and why both speeches weren’t filmed for YouTube, I don’t know. (If they were filmed, they need to be made available for the whole world to see. I teach storytelling at Pratt Institute, and I’d love for my students to see Laura Amy Schlitz as a model of great storytelling and delivery. It was amazing watching her hold that audience. Gave me goosebumps.) It’s not enough just to read or hear those speeches–and nowadays, it can’t be too hard to film. People who couldn’t attend would have the You-Are-There experience, and I’ll bet it would bring lots more folks to the conference and the dinner in the future.

]]> By: Marc Aronson http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-748 Marc Aronson Wed, 02 Jul 2008 11:16:39 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-748 John: Wow, thanks for the correction and folks, make sure to get that bonus DVD John: Wow, thanks for the correction and folks, make sure to get that bonus DVD

]]> By: John Mason of Scholastic http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/comment-page-1/#comment-749 John Mason of Scholastic Wed, 02 Jul 2008 10:55:57 +0000 http://blogs.slj.com/nonfictionmatters/2008/06/30/the-best-and-worst-of-newbery-caldecott/#comment-749 Mark, you are right that "seeing is believing" and the Weston Woods CD set of recordings of the speeches contains a bonus DVD with Brian Selznick's visual presentation. So Weston Woods, like Horn Book, will give people the full experience of the speech. Mark, you are right that “seeing is believing” and the Weston Woods CD set of recordings of the speeches contains a bonus DVD with Brian Selznick’s visual presentation. So Weston Woods, like Horn Book, will give people the full experience of the speech.

]]>