Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Practically Paradise
Inside Practically Paradise

My First and why it should be Mi Primer

While struggling to meet the diverse language needs of my students, I have decided purchasing bilingual titles enslow logo My First and why it should be Mi Primerfrom Enslow is now one of my very first choices. If there is an English only set and a bilingual set available, with my limited resources, I’m going to choose the Bilingual set for my middle schoolers even if the ages targeted are younger.

Take the perfect example: My First Pet Bilingual Library from the American Humane Association and Enslow Publishers. Written by Linda Bozzo these 32 page titles are intended for grade levels 1-3 but perfectly met the needs of my 5 ELD (English Language Development) classes who are mainly at the very beginning levels of English. They were able to concentrate on extracting meaning and information rather than focusing upon difficult vocabulary and complicated sentence structure.

Having both English and Spanish on the same page including English and Spanish captions, fills some of the white space that would otherwise draw attention to the fact that these titles are written for beginning readers. The middle school students who tested these titles for me were not embarassed to be caught reading them by their friends. (Don’t laugh! That’s a big deal in middle school)

The students were engaged with the titles and pointed out the sentences that helped them the most were written in the second-person narrative like these:

"Your horse will need a grassy field to run and graze in. You can board your horse at a stable. This means you will have to pay someone to house your horse."

I wrote about my dashing into the ELD classroom and thrusting this series into poor Mr. S’s hands. "I NEED your students to tell me what they think of these titles," I begged. They chose to write a combination of opinion piece, review, and research study to tell me what they thought of the books. Here are some of the pages they shared with me. I did give them the option of writing in any language and reminded them that I wouldn’t be editing their responses. 

My First Fish
9780766030367 My First and why it should be Mi Primer

 Mi Primer Fish

Los peces doredo no viven no cristalina la mayoria de los pese tropicales nesesita aqua tibia. Tambien los pese tropicales nesesita mas cuidado. 
Tambien los pese del mar nesesitan aqua salade. The part que mes me gusta is Que necesitara mi nuevo pez?
Para que los peseras esten complete y para que los pesen no se nuevan nesesitas a air pump end thermometer. Esto is 10 que I like.

Mi primer pez/My First Fish
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3036-7
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95 
There are two different kinds of goldfish that I like. They are orange and the thing is that they are so cute. 

What I don’t like is that you have to clean the fish tank. 

I like all the kinds of fish but the one I most like is the goldfish and I have 5 goldfish’s. 

I don’t like cleaning the tank.

My First Guinea Pig and Other Small Pets
9780766030374 My First and why it should be Mi Primer I like the book because it talks about animales like my favorite hamsters. I like hamsters because it is easy to take care of it. What I don’t like is that you have to put it in a cage and I don’t like that some of the hamsters are really messy.
Mi primera mascota pequena/My 
First Guinea Pig and Other Small Pets
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3037-4
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95 

I Don’t Like:
* I don’t like to clean the cage of my animal.
* I don’t like when my animal has long nails.
* I don’t like your eyes in the night. He is an animal ugly when I see your eyes in the night.

I Like:
* I like to play with my animal y so pretty.
* I like to give food in your mouth.
* I like when a hamster is white like when you see in the page #7 in this book.
* I like all animals beautiful.  

I like the picture how the book is illustrated and I think this book should be for sale.
My First Horse
9780766030350 My First and why it should be Mi Primer  I liked that the book teaches you how to take care of horses. It teaches you where it should live, what to feed it, and what it will need.

What I didn’t like about the book is that it was short and I like reading nonfiction books that are at least 40 pages long.

Mi primer caballo/My First Horse
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3035-0
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95
This book is about horses. I like this book because abla como escojer un buen caballo. Y tambien abla de que existen many different kinds of horses. A great place to get a horse rescue group in otro buen lugar para conseguir cabllo es en sociedad humanitania. When picking a horse is good to have a vet look at the horse. Tambien nesesitas saber su edad y si tiene buena salud.
Este libro ese de caballos. A mi me encanto los paliminos. Los paliminos son mis favoritos su color me encunta estan hermoses. Me encanta que los veterinarios esten al pendiente de los caballos.
My First Bird
9780766030343 My First and why it should be Mi Primer   No me gusto proque aleunas veces se enferman los pajantos y abeces se muenen leso es lo que a mi no me gusta.

Y lo que me gusta es que lo gana 1. Iimpia y puedes jugar con el y tambien le puedes ensena a hablar.

I don’t like because sometimes the birds is dead and is so sad.

I like teaching the bird. It is so pretty because you can lteach him to speak and he learns. I once had a bird in Honduras but he died.

Mi primer pajarito/My First Bird
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3034-3
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95

Description: Which bird is the best for me? 
Now in Spanish and English, with help from 
the American Humane Association, this book 
explores how to choose the right bird and how 
to care for your new pet. Learn what your 
new pet bird will need to stay healthy and 
happy in your home.

Well, about this book I like everything especially because it shows you how to keep your pet clean and safe. And 1 thing I don’t like? Well, I like everything about it and I don’t dislike anything. 

Bueno sobre este libro me gusta todo especialmente porque te ensena como cuidar a tus animales y mantener los limpios y seguros. Y una cosa que no me gusta bueno me gusten todo sobre el libro Y no ay ninguren cosa que no me gusta.

My First Dog
9780766030329 My First and why it should be Mi Primer

 

I like that dogs have all kinds of sizes. I can pick a kind of dog or pupply. 

I do not like that with dogs you have to go outside and wait for 45 minutes just to poo or pee. 

I like about this that you can get a collar with a tag and have fun with dogs. 

I do not like when they are just born or we have to wait when they are very little.

Mi primer perroo/My First Dog
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3032-9
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95
A great place to find a dog is at an animal shelter.

Some people adopt dogs from friends or neighbors. 

There are many dogs and animals that need families. 

A dog should have his own special place to sleep or rest.

A dog will need food and clean water.

The book is right. It is so exciting to have a dog as a pet. And it’s right because it does bring in love and fun in the family. 

But the most scariest thing is seeing your dog to the doctor to get a shot. It’s very scary because, your dog as soon as he sees the needle, it starts to cry. It’s very scary. 

But the most cutest thing is when you come home and see your dog waiting for you to come.

My First Cat
9780766030336 My First and why it should be Mi Primer   I like this book because it tells me how to take care of cats and what you should do to make sure it’s healthy. And what to do to find a pet? You need a microchip.
Mi Primer Gato/My First Cat
Author: Linda Bozzo
ISBN-13: 978-0-7660-3033-6
Publication Year: 2008
List price: $22.60
School & Library 
Discount: $16.95
My first cat

I like to play with the cats. But I don’t like to wash the box. Watching them is fun. I like clear eyes. Cats like to play with me. I like brown and white hair.

My favorite thing about cats is how you can take care of them. The cats are really cute. All the tips are good tips in this book. 

The thing I don’t like about cats is that their hair falls out a lot. And the cat litter stinks a lot.