Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Practically Paradise
Inside Practically Paradise

Comic books & Stone Arch got me in trouble

If Stone Arch didn’t create such interesting titles, that group of boys might have put down the 4 books I had (2 9781434211552 Comic books & Stone Arch got me in troubleBatman and 2 Superman titles) and gone to their next class. Instead those boys were so entranced that they sat in the reading area and kept reading through half another period beyond their class. Whenever someone asked what they were doing, they said, "Ms Chen told us to read these."  Finally I had to pay attention to what was going on and confront them. 

Sheepishly they admitted that, yes, I had told them to stay in the library with those 4 books because they hadn’t been processed and I needed to review them. They also admitted that they were having such a good time chatting about the books and reading them with other people that they had just stayed and stayed and stayed. Other boys would drop by and they’d hand them a title and say, "You gotta read these and tell Ms Chen if they’re any good." They knew the bell had rung but they were still reading.

Michael Dahl and Eric Stevens, you two may have to warn me if your books are going to entrance my students. I thought I was simply sharing four Super DC Heroes titles. Little did I know that I’d be starting an underground movement. Students slide up beside me and ask where I’m keeping "those books that got so-and-so in trouble." 

I asked the students if they thought I should give these books to another nearby elementary school. "NO!" they shouted. I stepped back and rethought. Then I asked, "If I were to keep these and purchase another set, do you think the elementary school would like them?" Yes, they did think that was a good idea. As long as these four books didn’t leave the library. They leaned towards me intimidatingly and said, "Make sure you don’t lose these."

Tonight one of the girls was waiting on the front steps for her ride so I sat down to keep her company. "Tell me what you think of these books," I said. She read through them and agreed that they were going to be big hits among the boys. When I mentioned that next year some female Super DC Heroes were coming like WonderWoman, she really lit up. "I’d really rather read about girl superheroes," she said. She told me that guys get all the good stuff when everyone knows its the girls that are the real strong ones. "And when did you say you’d have that WonderWoman book?" she asked. 

Uh, oh! I see potential trouble here. Am I going to have more teachers calling and asking if I have lured their students away from class with my good books? Who would guess these 48 page titles could instantly invoke such strong feelings? 

9781434211576 Comic books & Stone Arch got me in troubleLet’s look at them. Superman: The Museum Monsters was written by Michael Dahl and illustrated by Dan Schoening. I love the villain of this title – Mr. Mxyzptlk. Who cares if its hard to say? The students liked Superman’s frustrations. What? There is a plot and development in this book?! Amazing. As the students told me, there are not TOO many pictures to make it seem babyish. It’s a totally cool book to carry around even though it’s a novel. 

I preferred Superman: Last Son of Krypton written by Michael Dahl (who must never sleep) and illustrated by John Delaney and Lee Loughridge. Again in simply 5 chapters this title achieves admirable depth. We learn of Superman’s home world (true to the original, ye loyal fans) and gain a sense of the young Clark Kent caring for his foster family. Well done, team. 

On to the two Batman titles. Now, I have to tell you that secretly (oh well, not so secretly since it’s in my blog), I am a huge Catwoman fan. I like cats, shiny objects, and taking the things I want, with maybe a little romance with the big mysterious guy once in awhile to humanize me. Amoral? Immoral? Let’s forget those grown-up words and focus on the books readers.

9781434211491 Comic books & Stone Arch got me in troubleBatman: The Revenge of Clayface was written by Eric Stevens and illustrated by Gregg Schigiel and Lee Loughridge. Sometimes a parent wonders how they can convey their love of a character and their background knowledge without co-opting the discovery experience of comics for kids. (Well, if you don’t you should!)  Clayface is a great character who can’t easily be labeled good guy or bad guy. He is out solely for revenge, but so is Batman. I like the way this title causes the reader to pause and think about motivations. Oh, yes, Joker makes an appearance and we all love/hate the Joker.

The last of the four in my hands is Batman: Emperor of the Airwaves written by Donald Lemke and illustrated by the team of Erik Doescher, Mike DeCarlo, and Lee Loughridge. My favorite line? "Blasted! Fooled by a bird (girl) with a brain!" Librarians will appreciate the ending of 9781434211538 Comic books & Stone Arch got me in troublethis title. Teachers will attempt to use the discussion questions and writing prompts. Kids will ignore the teachers and simply enjoy the books. 

Oh, no! What’s this I see at the end? A page showing 6 titles in each series?! Don’t those rascals at Stone Arch realize that my students are going to march in and demand we purchase more?! These publishers are getting too clever. Now I’m going to have to go out and purchase more books in the series.

Well, readers, if you have students who request "comic books," these titles are going to satisfy them with the characters while tricking them into actually R-E-A-D-I-N-G words in a novel format. So far, the students don’t mind.

Comments

  1. Michael Dahl says:

    Tell those boys, from me, that they gave an author the BEST review he could ever receive — they couldn’t put the book down! Every author dreams of having such terrific, smart, loyal, intelligent readers. Even Stephen King and J.K. Rowling would give their arm and leg (and King probably has!) to get such cool readers who love their books.

  2. Mary says:

    The books offered by Stone Arch have attracted many boys in my library also. Normally these students would continue to cko I Spy books.

  3. Claudia says:

    Anything that gets my kids away from I Spy books is ok in my “book”! What’s the reading level?CUA

  4. Diane says:

    Sorry, I did post a comment, but even I have trouble here sometimes. Let’s try again. These titles are aimed at a grade 2-3 reading level. The interest is much higher. Many students are reading them “behind my desk” In fact, they told me not to put the barcode on them too soon because then just one person gets to read them at a time. I wonder if they want me to keep a section of graphic novels and books like these on RESERVE in the library. For more info, go to stonearchbooks.com

  5. Online Stock Trading says:

    Hey, great blog…but I don’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me, please :)

  6. Online Stock Investing says:

    Your site was extremely interesting, especially since I was searching for thoughts on this subject last Thursday.

  7. Online Stock Investing says:

    Hey, I read a lot of blogs on a daily basis and for the most part, people lack substance but, I just wanted to make a quick comment to say GREAT blog!…..I”ll be checking in on a regularly now….Keep up the good work! :)

  8. Online Stock Trading says:

    I usually don’t post on Blogs but ya forced me to, great info.. excellent! … I’ll add a backlink and bookmark your site.