Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: Nothing

Nothingnothing Review: Nothing by Janne Teller, translated from the Danish by Martin Aitken. Atheneum Books for Younger Readers, an imprint of Simon & Schuster. 2010. Originally published in Danish as Intet in 2000. Personal copy.

The Plot: On the first day of school, Pierre Anthon announces to his classmates, “Nothing matters. I’ve know that for a long time. So nothing’s worth doing. I just realized that.” He walks away, climbs the tree in front of his house, and taunts his classmates. “It’s all a waste a time.”In a few years you’ll all be dead and forgotten and didly-squat, nothing, so you might just as well start getting used to it!” Good in school? “ There’ll always be someone who is better.” Fame and achievement may be in your future? “And then you’ll find out that fame and the big wide world are outside of you, and inside there’s nothing, and always will be, no matter what you do.” Love? “First you fall in love, then you start dating, then you fall out of love, and then you split up again.”

Agnes and her classmates realize quickly they have to get Pierre Anthon out of the tree. They have to stop him telling them that they, their hopes, fears, present, are nothing. “We didn’t want to live in the world Pierre Anthon was telling us about.”

They try words. They try stones. Pierre Anthon stays in the tree and his taunts continue. Finally they come up with a plan: They will prove to him that life has meaning, that it is more than nothing. They will collect things that matter to prove Pierre Anthon wrong. Will it work? What will be found, and lost, along the way?

The Good: This is a stunning, heart shattering, haunting book that will result in many discussions about whether Pierre Anthon is right or wrong in his philosophy, as well as the reactions  and actions of his peers. How far will Agnes (the narrator) and her friends will go to stop Pierre Anthon?

Nothing is the first translated work to receive a Printz Honor; it was originally published in Denmark in 2000. The translator’s note explains that the translation retains much of the original. Names remain the same; the setting is still a Danish town, the grade still called seventh even though the closer American fit is eighth, both age wise (ages 13 and 14) and school wise (it is the last year of school before moving up to a larger school). Unexplained in the note is the decision to retain the original dates of the book: it is set in the school year 1992 to 1993. Those more familiar with Denmark may see significance in those years.

Agnes tells this story, and her tone brings you into the story, so you share the fear and frustration and growing anger she and her classmates feel about Pierre Anthon and what they are “forced” to do to stop him. The format of the story is wonderful. Various sections of the book (not always chapter headings) contain a handful of words, chilling in their starkness sentence, standing alone in the middle of the page. They introduce something that will be said (Pierre Anthon’s original statement of nothingness) or emphasize an action (“It was then that Pierre Anthon stood up.”) Pay attention, this tells us. These words matter.

I looked down at my bare feet and decided Gerda was going to pay.” Up to this point, the “heap of meaning”  the teens put together are objects that matter to them. An old doll, a hymnbook, things collected from neighbors. The heap of meaning grows, but was what was being collected really a collection of things that mattered? Dennis is forced to hand over his complete Dungeons & Dragons books after he attempts to hold back four, so he turns on Sebastian to give up his fishing rod, who makes Richard give up his soccer ball, who then makes Laura forsake her favorite earrings.

At that point, Agnes tries to deflect attention from her newly acquired green wedge sandals but Gerda doesn’t fall for it. The sandals join the heap of meaning. Home without her sandals, Agnes thinks “I looked down at my bare feet and decided Gerda was going to pay.” The teens have gotten to the heart of it: the pile of meaning must contain that which is truly meaningful. They have also begun to stray, because the motivation changes. It is now about finding not what is most meaningful to someone, but, rather, what will hurt someone else the most. All the better if the someone else was instrumental in your own loss. The pressure and, yes, manipulation steadily increase as the teens realize the power they have over each other.

This is the perfect example of the deep discussions that can result from Nothing. Does this change in motivation matter? How do you define what has meaning? Is it what someone else decides? Is it what hurts the most to give up? How does that meaning shift now that it’s been sacrificed, and can it be restored? As the book ends, as this tale plays out to its chilling, inevitable end, do Agnes and her friends succeed in creating a heap of meaning? Do they discover the meaning of Nothing? Do they discover meaning? And, if so, at what price?

This is a bleak, dark book. It is not double rainbows and ponies. Personally, I was blown away by it and think it’s a great book and am pleased to see it get recognition. That said, many people will hate it — not because it’s a bad book but because it is not a happy, hopeful book. Bad things happen.I can easily see people confusing their distaste for where this book goes (and it goes there) with a judgment on the book itself. That would be a mistake.  Nothing is unsettling. It won’t be for every reader, true. But those readers who it is for? Will adore it; will love that there is something out there that is more than sparkle and false hope and romance. They will love a book that asks hard questions without easy answers, a book that will give them a safe place to grapple with tough questions. It is for teens who are already reading bleak, sad, haunting books, of course. You know you have them in your library. Let them know up front: this book will bother you. This book will make you mad. This book will make you think.

share save 171 16 Review: Nothing
About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is lizzy.burns@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. Melissa says:

    At Annual 2010, I was hanging around in the S&S booth when a group of teens came over. When one of them found out that Atheneum, an imprint of S&S, was the publisher of Nothing, she flipped out–especially when she got to meet Janne Teller’s agent. The teen was so enthusiastic about this very dark book, so I wanted to share this anecdote to reinforce your point, Liz. Nothing isn’t for everyone, but for those teens who discover it and respond to the novel, it could be a real life-changer.

  2. Mark Flowers says:

    I think you’re absolutely right about the likely love/hate reactions to the book, but I actually felt very differently. I really liked the dark existential stuff (seems like Scandinavians have a real talent for it), but I got hung up on more basic stuff like plot, character, and writing. Not that any of those were bad, per se, but just that they didn’t live up to the ideas the book was wrestling with, for me. (and I know when I say “writing” I actually mean “translation of someone else’s writing” but I don’t know Danish, so that’s all I’ve got to go on).

  3. Jennifer W. says:

    Ok, now I have to know…what’s the significance of the years in Denmark? What happened? The Danish Superliga? but that was season 3, so….I must know!

  4. Hope says:

    I haven’t touched this book because I am afraid it is another Boy in the Striped Pajamas. I hate fables. Should I reconsider? Or is a fable hater likely not to like it?

  5. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Melissa, yay, nothing like being proved right. :-) Intellectually we know teens are reading more than Twilight etc but it’s always good to hear it! Because we all serve so many teens, we don’t always get that direct feedback about our books.

    Mark, I kept on thinking some of the same things about the dark, existential stuff. There were a few things that initially bugged me about plot, but init erms of what wasn’t said, but when I reread I realized that this was being told by Agnes six years later, so not only is it distorted thru her view (and she isn’t exactly the voice of reason) but also the passage of time. So for me, part of that got resolved by remembering it is Agnes’s story.

    Jennifer, I have no idea, but I assume it had to be important! Maybe I am making significance where this is none.

  6. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Hope, I’ve never read The Boy In The Striped Pajamas. I’m not sure if “fable” is quite the right word to describe this book. It is dark and nightmarish and unrelenting. I’d compare it more to Sonya Hartnett’s works.

  7. Elizabeth Bird says:

    If any book was the antithesis of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, it is this. It’s amazing. Fable isn’t quite the term for it, though, I agree. Neither is “allegory”. It sort of busts all conventional limitations. I was rather blown away by it myself.

  8. SArah says:

    I read this aloud to me seniors last semester, and plan to do the same with my new class this semester. While they were reading LORD OF THE FLIES, I read this aloud. They were stunned by it.

    I was blown away by this one and have been recommending it to everyone I know. Great review!

    sarah

  9. TerryD says:

    I really like dark books. “The Road” is a favorite, for example. Perhaps I miss-read this, but I didn’t find it terribly moving or disturbing, just kind of clunky and slow. Clearly, a bunch of folks don’t agree with me, but I really feel that “Nothing” was didactic, and not in a good way.

  10. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Betsy, that reminds me that NOTHING also got on the ALSC notables list! Quite the number of lists & awards.

    Sarah, LORD OF THE FLIES came to mind as I was reading this.

    Terry, I’d be lying if I didn’t admit that at various points during my reading of NOTHING I didn’t say, “just cut down the darn tree already” or “can you kids stop obsessing, it’s been months, don’t any of you have anything else going on in your lives” or “what is the deal with this kid’s father and the school system that this has gone on for nine months, c’mon, really?” With a side of “not one kid in class just says, ‘who really cares’ and ignores him?” While sorting it out in my head, I think part of it is Agnes telling the tale and she’s quite the twisted narrator tho she holds it in check for most of the book. All that to say, I understand where you’re coming from for this one.

  11. Ray says:

    I just had one question… who is the main character? Pierre or Agnes?

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Other reviews at: Book Envy, Opps… Wrong Cookie, The Ya Ya Yas, Ms. Yingling Reads, and A Chair, a Fireplace and a Tea Cozy. [...]

  2. [...] reviews: A Chair, A Fireplace & A Tea Cozy, Oops…Wrong Cookie, DogEar, Bookish [...]

Speak Your Mind

*