Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: The Whole Story of Half a Girl

The Whole Story of Half a Girlwholestory 197x300 Review: The Whole Story of Half a Girl by Veera Hiranandani. Delacorte Press, an imprint of Random House. 2012. Reviewed from copy from publisher.

The Plot: When eleven-year-old Sonia’s father loses his job, she has to leave private school for public school. At her old school, everyone knew her; now, they wonder if she’s Indian like her father or Jewish like her mother. She’s trying to make new friends and keep in touch with old ones. To make matters worse, her father’s unemployment is taking more than a financial toll on her family. It’s also emotional. One day, he just doesn’t come home.

The Good: Sonia’s old school was a private school, yes; but it’s not that type of private school. It was one that emphasized nurturing and non-traditional learning and not having tests. Honestly? It sounds like a terrific school, and I can understand why Sonia doesn’t want to leave! On the other hand, her parents say that part of the reason they want to send her to public school is so she can receive more traditional learning. I can understand that, also.

Sonia makes new friends, yes, but she is also exposed to cliques for the first time. Her old school was just too small (and touchy-feely) for that. Also? Sonia observes that the students self segregate by skin tone. She wonders, what table does she belong at? She also has to put up with obnoxious/ignorant remarks about her parents, especially about being half Indian. Because her mother isn’t very religious, she also wonders whether she’s really Jewish or not.

The Whole Story of Half a Girl is a fascinating look at class and money. Sonia’s family is well educated, live in a big house, travel, and (until recently) paid private school tuition. One of her new friends, Kate, has a stay at home mother. Kate’s mother shops a lot and the family eats take out all the time, but they live in a smaller house than Sonia’s. Kate (and her mother) also introduce Sonia to cheerleading, something Sonia’s mother frowns on. Sonia doesn’t make any conclusions about careers or spending, but it’s interesting to read between the lines. Students are bussed to Sonia’s school, and that, too, adds a socioeconomic spin to this story. It’s done with a soft touch, such as when Alisha invites Sonia home with her after school, a trip that is more complicated than walking home with someone.

Kate is the popular girl; it would be easy to say she’s the “mean” girl. It’s more complex than that, and I ended up feeling sorry for her. Kate ends up letting Sonia down, true; but Kate comes to the friendship with her own complex background that impacts what Kate does or does not do. I’d be curious to discuss this aspect with others; am I letting Kate off the hook? One more thing: the mean comments about Sonia’s ethnicity (and they are mean) come just as much from the boys as the girls. I liked that touch, because sometimes it seems like books (and people) use “mean” as something girls do and that boys don’t.

Sonia’s father suffers from depression.  I like how it’s handled; it’s shown over an extended time period, and the impact on the family (especially Sonia) takes center stage.

One last thing: there is no forced happy “we’ll all sit at one table together” ending. It’s not an after school special. I was so relieved by that!

Other reviewsThe Happy Nappy Bookseller; S. Krishna’s Books; Mixed Reader; Masala Reader.

share save 171 16 Review: The Whole Story of Half a Girl
About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is lizzy.burns@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. MotherReader says:

    I wished that Sonia wouldn’t have written off Kate so quickly – or her own interest in cheerleading. Both choices felt forced. Kate isn’t perfect, but the friendship expands Sonia’s circle and experience. Nothing wrong with that. I liked the book very much, but that bothered me a bit.

  2. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Pam, I’m trying to sort out my feelings about Kate. One thing I saw; from Kate’s point of view, it looks like Sonia dropped her once Kate spoke about her own biological father. And I wonder, if that played into it, a bit? Because Alisha didn’t seem much to offer beyond her romance novel, and Sonia wasn’t quite into that.

  3. MotherReader says:

    It surprised me that a book that seemed willing to explore the complexities of people, the shades of gray, ended with such a black-or-white conclusion. Somewhat literally. A key concept in the book was the idea of not being labeled or boxed in, but then the end seems to turn that around by making Sonia chose sides and give up something that she might just like because she didn’t like some aspects of it. And yeah, Kate says something not cool, but it just revealed her own insecurities. Maybe they could talk about that, as friends.

    There was a lot to like in this book, but I felt like it went for a tidy ending when untidy would have fit better with the theme and the characters.

  4. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    In terms of the ending: what I ended up deciding was that my tween self would want such a conclusion. That to her, what Kate had or hadn’t done with the party, and the not speaking up, would be a deal breaker.

Speak Your Mind

*