Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: The Dark Unwinding

The Dark Unwinding by Sharon Cameron. Scholastic. 2012. Review copy from publisher.

darkunwinding 198x300 Review: The Dark UnwindingThe Plot: June, 1852. England. Orphaned Katherine Tulman owes everything to her Aunt Alice. Not in a good way. When Katherine was left orphaned, Alice was the one who took in her late husband’s niece. Aunt Alice makes it known that in every possible way that without Alice, Katherine would be on the streets. With nothing. Aunt Alice fears that her husband’s eldest brother is spending all his money, which will mean nothing left for Alice’s son.

Aunt Alice’s instructions are clear: Katherine is to travel to Stranwyne Keep, the family estate. Get proof that her uncle is incapable of handling his own affairs. Report back to Aunt Alice and her solicitors, so that Alice can seize control of the family fortune and property on behalf of the sole living heir, her own son, Robert. (The family property goes strictly to the eldest living male heir, so Katherine, as a female, is excluded.) Katherine agrees, because as a poor orphan with no prospects, her only hope for future food and shelter is that young Robert gains his inheritance so he can, like his mother before him, take care of the poor relative.

Katherine arrives at Stranwyne. She meets her uncle Frederick. Aunt Alice is both right, and wrong, about what is happening with her uncle and the Tulman fortune. Her uncle is child-like, who lives with odd self-imposed rules and is also a brilliant inventor. Money has been spent on the inventions; but money has also been spent in taking 900 men, women and children from the workhouses of London to create a community that, given time, will not just be self-sufficient but also a source of income. The longer Katherine stays, the more she becomes attached to her uncle and the local villagers; but she cannot forget that it is her aunt who ensures her future. What should she do?

The Good: Uncle Frederick’s inventions are, for the most part, automatons. The descriptions of them seem almost fantastical; but this is not a story of magic or fantasy. It’s historical fiction, and the described automatons reflect the science of the day. Cameron’s website includes links to some videos of automatons. Stranwyne is also based in historic reality: Welbeck Abbey. I love how two of the aspects of this book are things that seem so unreal or unlikely that one could think The Dark Unwinding is a fantasy. It is not. Instead, it’s the type of historical fiction I really enjoy, grounded in lesser-known history.

Katherine is an interesting character, between a rock and a hard place. Aunt Alice is a nasty bit of business. When Katherine meets some resistance and suspicion from her uncle’s employees, Katherine thinks “the normalcy of being in a room with with a woman who despised me had restored some of my common sense.” Katherine, despite herself, wants more from life even if she cannot voice it, cannot dream it. She decides to delay reporting back to her aunt, and as each day goes by, she grows closer to the villagers: the housekeeper/cook, Mrs. Jeffries; her 18 year old nephew, Lane; Davy, a young mute boy; Ben Aldridge, an engineering student from Cambridge studying her uncle’s inventions. All seem to share a common goal: convince Katherine to not tell the truth about Uncle Tully’s condition. Are their friendships, are the flirtations of Lane and Ben, to be trusted? Katherine isn’t even sure she can trust herself: she starts sleepwalking and having memory loss.

I loved the idea of the Tulman family (Frederick’s mother, not his brothers or his sister in law) trying to figure out a way to protect Frederick and the money; and the solution of creating a self-sufficient village. Invest in crafts and industry, an investment of several years, and yes, it will cost money at first, but in the long run it creates a home and livelihood for people in addition to preserving enough family money. I also loved Uncle Tully and his inventions. Can all these people survive Aunt Alice and the laws that seem to be on her side? I also loved the Stranwyne Keep itself: full of rooms and hallways and pathways.

Finally, I loved that The Dark Unwinding surprised me. First, by not being a fantasy. Second, by it’s interesting look at history. Next, by Katherine herself, damaged and hurt and learning for the first time to trust and love. Finally – the ending! So unexpected yet it makes sense. And it’s brave because it makes sense but it’s not what the reader wants. The Dark Unwinding rather gives the reader what he needs. A good story.

Other reviews: The Book Smugglers; Reading Everywhere; The Ninja Librarian (and author interview).

share save 171 16 Review: The Dark Unwinding
About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is lizzy.burns@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. Brandy says:

    Thanks for reviewing this. I hadn’t heard of it, but will definitely be looking for it now.

  2. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Brandy, let me know what you think!

  3. Lisa says:

    I’m on a roll with my book choices lately. This was tremendous! I kept having happy flashes of Joan Aiken as I read along.

    Also, did you notice how Katharine echoed her uncle’s full-blown Asperger/autistic traits? She had a facility with numbers, counted her steps as she walked in a couple scenes (when no one else was present), and rocked back and forth a couple times while anxiously waiting for something to happen.

    The very end worked for me. He’s got to go away and see a bit of the world before he can come back and settle down. However, I did mind the consequences of the flood. I didn’t fully believe what had happened until they were sitting by the grave. Then it was kleenex time.

    And finally, I’m a little annoyed that it’s being called steampunk because it’s not! Let it be a regular ole historical/gothic novel; there’s nothing wrong with that, and frankly that genre could use a little boosterism.

  4. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Lisa, good call with the Joan Aiken! Yes. I hadn’t picked up on the similiarites with Katherine; one point I liked was that she was both distrustful enough of others, but also concerned enough about being like her uncle, that when that certain something happened, instead of thinking “this is crazy, let me talk to somebody” she believed “i’m crazy, let me do something to stop myself.” Now that you mention those other things, all the more reason she believed it to be her. And I so agree re steampunk — I was so pleased when it turned out not to be steampunk! (At one point, not realizing it was straight history, I wondered whether all the people were really automatons).

  5. Eliza says:

    I finished this over the long weekend. Such a good read. Yes – no insta-love and no love triangles! So over those. I loved Katharine. What I thought was amazing was given her upbringing and lack of love received, she was not a bitter or hard person. While reserved, she did not close herself off from others but remained open to them. When she thought “the normalcy of being in a room with with a woman who despised me had restored some of my common sense,” it just made me so sad for her.

    I think that one of the reasons she was able to communicate so well with her uncle is because she had similar traits as he did (and you got a hint that her father did also). How could you not love Uncle Tully? I wanted to see into his workshop, especially on winding day. Automatons – an added bonus! It’s not often you get to say that about a book.

    It’s so interesting about the real Welbeck Abbey. Like you, I loved that the story was based on historical precedent.

  6. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Eliza, yes, another great point — she wasn’t made hard by her life so far, at least, not in a shut the whole world out forever way. And the sympathy she felt for Uncle Tully! The more I think about it all, the more I like it

Speak Your Mind

*