Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Fuse #8 Production
Inside A Fuse #8 Production

Review of the Day: Bad Island by Doug TenNapel

Bad Island
By Doug TenNapel
Coloring by Katherine Garner
Graphix (an imprint of Scholastic)
ISBN: 978-0-545-31479-4
Ages 10-14
On shelves August 1, 2011

It’s enough to make you want to take up brain surgery. I read some comics for kids and I can hardly move through the recycled tropes and old overdone ideas cluttering up the pages. Then I read a book by Doug TenNapel. When the man’s Ghostopolis came out last year I was delighted. Sure, we’ve all seen the idea of the afterlife as a city done before (May Bird, Billy Bones, etc.) but TenNapel’s storytelling managed to incorporate this odd and unique internal logic that I’d never seen anywhere before. Now I’ve picked up his next Graphix GN Bad Island and while I wish I could just compare it to something I’ve seen before I cannot. What currently operates in the brain of this man baffles me. His books read like fever dreams that make sense (and if rumors about his next cardboard-related comic are to be believed he’s not exactly going mainstream anytime soon). Sometime a kid wants a stand alone graphic novel that also happens to be “epic”. And if it’s epic you seek, epic you will find in this strange near-indescribable little piece.

Okay. Here comes the tough part of the review. The part where I try to summarize the plot. Bear with me now. Two planets. Two rebellious sons. In a distant universe a battle wages. Giant creatures have secured the freedom of a relatively tiny species that they allow to live on their very skin. The giants rely on these people to operate their battle armor and other internal mechanics, which is a good thing since the tiny people’s previous hosts have returned to reclaim their slaves. The son of the king of the giants is determined to fight as well, but his efforts lead only to his capture at the hands of the enemy and banishment to a far away world. Meanwhile, centuries later here on earth, teenaged Reese is trying desperately to figure out how to get out of the lame family vacation his dad has planned. No one seems thrilled to be taking a boat ride, not Reese or his mom or his snake-obsessed little sister Janie. And that’s before the family gets caught up in a freak storm and shipwrecks on a strange deserted island. There they find creatures the like of which they’ve never seen, a strange artifact that appears to be leading them somewhere, and a malevolent presence that wants something that they have and is willing to do anything it can to get it back.

I recently had a conversation with a children’s author about whether or not kids vs. teens prefer series books with cliffhanger endings. We both agreed that in our experience kids are actually less delighted by series than their older counterparts. A child between the ages of 9-12 is more interested in a bit of smart storytelling. Sometimes seeing a “1” on the spine just frustrates them. One of TenNapel’s more remarkable qualities is the fact that he creates perfect little worlds that have no need of sequels. None at all. Now the danger of creating your own mythology is that no one else is going to buy it. And the best way to make them buy into it is to make it horrendously long or the first in a series. That TenNapel consistently packs whole worlds into his books without making them (A) 500 pages long or (B) The first of a 10-book series or (C) incoherent isn’t just rare in this day and age. It’s near impossible to find in any other GN author for kids. Thank god he actually has the chutzpah to pull it off.

Myth making is all well and good, but what sets this book apart from the usual heroic narrative pack is the family element. At the heart of this story is a tale about getting to know (and care about) your siblings and parents in the midst of true danger. As such, the book fleshes out a family that not only rings true on the page but that you want to know more about. I think the moment when I was completely on board with them was when Janie insisted on lugging her dead snake with her wherever the family went. The gentle macabre nature of this just struck me as oddly real. Then there’s the change that comes over Reese’s dad, from bumbling to capable. I was also fairly pleased that the mom could hold her own and didn’t need any of the typical rescuing moms tend to lend themselves to in books of this sort. I was also pleased to see that there’s more than a jot of humor to this story. There are overt physical gags, like the dad getting bitten by the snake and (my personal favorite) managing to light all the matches in the matchbox on fire at once. But there are subtler spoken gags as well, and a real family camaraderie and back and forth that makes you believe in these people. Interestingly, I found the sections with the humans far more interesting than the ones with the giants. As it should be.

And for the art? TenNapel has a distinctive style that reveals itself in sharp jaw lines and akimbo elbows. At the same time he knows how to keep a page interesting. Shadows and scenes seen from different angles appear alongside variegated panel sizes and consistently interesting layouts. There’s a controlled messiness to TenNapel’s style that serves him here. With this book he can use his style to bring forth the dirt and grime of the outdoors. Indeed I think he’d have a harder time if he ever set one of his stories in a pristine, clean, robotic world. His is an art of well-ordered chaos, on the edge of going entirely insane. Nothing bad really happens to our heroes in this book, but you are never in any doubt that it would take surprisingly little to change that fact. The lure of TenNapel’s art is that it verges on the insane.

Actually, the book that this would pair the best with might be Don Wood’s own island-related graphic novel Into the Volcano. In both cases you have reluctant boy protagonists coming into their own to save their family members. Both also have a strange reluctance to trust an island. Wood, because they can always blow up or emit poison gas or try to kill you some other way. TenNapel because they might one day just up and leave with you still on them. On its own, however, Bad Island provides the mix of storytelling and action, heart and excitement, which many a graphic novel strives for and few actually attain. There’s substance to this puppy. Something that sticks long after you’ve read it. And for many a kid, that’ll be enough. Definitely check it out.

On shelves August 1st.

Source: Reviewed from galley sent by publisher for review.

Misc: We get a fair number of children’s book authors from the world of animation.  Less so the world of video game design.  TenNapel, however, may be best known at this point in time for his mid-1990s SEGA creation Earthworm Jim.  Reading and remembering that old game really backs up what I was saying earlier about wondering how the heck TenNapel’s brain operates.


My brother-in-law’s been an inker for DC Comics, so I know a little bit about the business.  This video is a fascinating look at how TenNapel digitally inked Bad Island himself.  But really, this is initially more of a look at how to make a graphic novel at all.  From thumbnails to scripts to storytelling, TenNapel tells everything.

About Elizabeth Bird

Elizabeth Bird is currently the Collection Development Manager of the Evanston Public Library system and a former Materials Specialist for New York Public Library. She has served on Newbery, written for Horn Book, and has done other lovely little things that she'd love to tell you about but that she's sure you'd find more interesting to hear of in person. Her opinions are her own and do not reflect those of EPL, SLJ, or any of the other acronyms you might be able to name. Follow her on Twitter: @fuseeight.


  1. Ooh! Looks great–I can’t wait! Great video too!

  2. Why do I feel like there’s an extra measure of integrity in a stand-alone book? For some reason the idea of a “self contained epic” does my heart good.

    Another great review, ma’am! Eyes now peeled for Bad Island. Thanks too for linking that great video.

  3. Great preview!! I can’t wait to check this out..Huge fan of Doug’s work.

  4. One of my students keeps asking me “When are you going to get new graphic novels like Ghostopolis?” so I can’t wait to buy this for my classroom!

  5. I loved “Ghostopolis”, and it circulates a lot at my library, so I’m really looking forward to this. Thanks for the review!

  6. Doug TenNapel is a force in comics and the world at large! I pre-ordered Bad Island months ago and can’t wait to check it out. Thanks for such a great, in-depth review of what’s sure to be another instant classic!

  7. If the only other TenApel book you’ve read is “Ghostopolis,” you’ve got a pleasant surprise waiting. Check out all his other great graphic novels. Won’t list them here, but there’s like nine of them.


  1. […] have to mark your calendars because this one’s not out until August, but you can see what SLJ’s Fuse8 Blog had to say about it in the […]