Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: Imaginary Girls

Imaginary Girls by Nova Ren Suma. Dutton Books, a member of Penguin. Reviewed from ARC from publisher.

The Plot: Two years ago, Chloe and her older sister Ruby were at a party at the reservoir. Dares and drinking, one thing leads to another, and Chloe’s classmate London Hayes is dead and Chloe leaves town, leaves Ruby, and goes to live with her father out of state.

It’s two years later. Chloe is coming home; returning to the town she left, the friends she left, returning to her sister, Ruby.

Two years away, and something seems off. Not quite right. Something is different with the town, with Ruby. At a party, Chloe comes face to face with the biggest difference of all; with something that just shouldn’t be.

The Good: Oh, how to do this without spoilers! How to explain the spell of Ruby, the web she weaves around all who know her. To know her is to love her. And as I write this, trying to both explain the magic and wonder of this book without revealing too much, I find that all I can write about is Ruby. All I want to write about is Ruby.

Ruby is a magical older sister, almost mythical to her younger sister, Chloe. Zoey Deschanel would play Ruby in a movie, with her sundresses and boots, her big old Buick with the gas gage that always reads E yet always has a few extra miles left in her, ex-boyfriends ready to do any favor she asks, because, well, it’s Ruby. Some people are like that; charismatic, magnetic. Everyone loves Ruby. Best of all, Ruby loves Chloe. She includes Chloe in her circle, makes her part of it, whether its a circle of friends or of family (Ruby has practically raised Chloe).

When Ruby says something is possible, it is.  When Ruby says Chloe is capable of something, she is.

For two years, Chloe has missed having someone believe in her so deeply, support her so completely: “Ruby could turn me from an ordinary girl you wouldn’t look at twice into someone worth watching, someone special, mythical even.”

Who wouldn’t want a bond like Ruby and Chloe’s?

But now, two years later, something is off, with Ruby, with that bond. Ruby has a secret, a secret she’s keeping from Chloe. Even when Chloe thinks she knows what it is, she isn’t even close to the truth.

What more can I say, without ruining the wonder, the discovery?

One of the things I love about Stephen King is his tone, his use of place, his build up of suspense. Suma does all this: the slowly increasing sense of dread, the creation of the town and reservoir and Ruby’s half-finished house, and, finally, the suspense as Ruby’s secrets begin to unravel, begin to get out of control. My heart is still racing, my mind still whirring, as I realize Ruby’s secrets. Once I knew (or, rather, thought I knew), I got to the last page and then turned to the first page and —  What would I see in the beginning, that would point the way to where Imaginary Girls goes? Or would I see something else? To be able to do that, to have a the book start as one thing, end as another, be both at the same time, is pretty fine writing. When I reread it, I saw so many clues, yet didn’t pick up on them the first time. Or, maybe I did, and that explained the growing sense of unease as I read.

Suma builds up the tension of what is happening in Chloe’s hometown, and at the same time shows this tight, amazing, bond between two sisters that makes the reader think, I want that. Ruby doesn’t see her life as one stuck taking care of her baby sister because her mother is the town drunk and their respective fathers skipped out long ago. Ruby instead has created a life for herself, and for her sister — before she went away — a life of watching movies, roller skating, hanging out at the Village Green, a life where each of those things is infused with fun. Ruby is the sister who texts, “my boots miss your feet” and “my head misses your hairbrush.” Ruby has a way of looking at the world; when Ruby decides a boy isn’t right for Chloe, she says, “Owen is too pretty. . . . There’s something ugly about a pretty boy who knows he’s pretty and assumes everyone else knows it, too.”  Ruby is the type of girl who, when she says she wants cheesecake from a certain restaurant hours away, the guy will drive to get it for her.

What does it mean to Chloe to have Ruby in her life? It means living a life that is a story worth telling. Without Ruby, life is ordinary. Even as the web of Ruby’s wonderfulness is spun, Suma builds the suspense. Something is not quite right. Ruby is hiding something; Ruby is different from what Chloe remembers. Little things strike the reader, like how Ruby doesn’t like to leave the town limits, and doesn’t want Chloe to, either. How Ruby lives in sight of the Reservoir, but puts Chloe in the only room without a view. How Ruby disappears.

The town, a town next to a reservoir, a live town next to a dead drowned town, because when the reservoir was created generations ago it killed the towns in its way. The people were told to leave, but Ruby whispers stories about the people who refused to leave their homes. It is a nameless town next to a dead town with a name; nameless tourists visit the Village Green. The town is special only because Ruby is there. And the reader has to understand just who Ruby is and what she means to Chloe, to understand why Chloe returns home . . . and why after she comes face to face with what is happening in town, she stays. A reader has to understand Ruby to understand what happens in town.

While reading Imaginary Girls, I though of people I’ve known like Ruby. The charismatic person that everyone wants to be around. But the further I read, the more I realized… I’ve never met anyone quite like her.

For other reviews, and to see how others address how to review this book without revealing all the secrets of Chloe, Ruby, their town and their friends — and to see some different views of Ruby:

The Book Smugglers: “Imaginary Girls is very creepy, uncomfortable and disturbing. In fact, it reads a lot like a Twilight Zone episode.” That gives a little bit away about what happens . . . but hey, my referring to Stephen King is also a clue.

Stacked: “Nova Ren Suma has created a deliciously creepy book full of odd happenings all seen through a sort of haze. It’s difficult to get a handle on what’s really going on, because Chloe herself isn’t always sure. That aspect gives the book a feeling of magical realism rather than straight up fantasy or paranormal. And even though Imaginary Girls has elements of the paranormal, which can be found in so many current YA books, you’ll come away from it knowing you’ve really never read anything like it.”

GalleySmith: “If it felt like I was talking in circles in this review it’s because that is exactly how this book made me feel.  Upside down then right side up, all in the best possible way.  Suma is one of the few authors I’ve read that I wouldn’t fear stepping outside of my typical reading boundaries to get hold of her stories.  I’d read anything, anywhere, anytime if she wrote it.”

Because I still cannot get Ruby out of my head. Because Chloe haunts me. Because I’m not quite sure what did or did not happen. Because I could talk about this book all night, over glasses of wine, and then all morning, over cups of coffee. Because the writing wrapped around me like a blanket. This is a Favorite Book Read in 2011.

My last words: if you’ve read Imaginary Girls and want to talk about just what did, or did not, happen, chat away in the comments! The rest of you — you’ve been warned.

About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is


  1. Reading your review makes me want to re-read this novel. The story has stayed with me longer than most other books I’ve read this year and, like you, I really want to sit down with someone and discuss this book…figure out what REALLY happened and why it all still haunts me.

    However, I am not nearly as enamored of Ruby as you seem to be. Your description of her as “almost mythical” is apt, but my problem is that she’s so much larger than life…to the point where she becomes almost predictable and (dare I say it?) boring in her excesses. The author keeps piling on the details about how every boy is at her command, how everyone in town lets Ruby do exactly as she pleases. I kept wishing that Ms. Suma had toned down this character a little — creating her with a few broad colorful brushstrokes, leaving her enigmatic but powerful. Instead, she’s such a BIG OVERSIZED NEON PORTRAIT that the character seems overwritten and overdetailed. For example, one scene describing her sending a boy on a midnight trek to NY to buy cheesecake was brilliant; seeing her exert similar control over boys several more times just feels like gillding the lily.

    As I said, I really need to re-visit IMAGINARY GIRLS. Maybe reading it again will help change my perspective. But at this point in time, I feel like the broad characterization of Ruby overwhelms the entire narrative and takes the edge off the chilling mystery at the center of this novel.

  2. Peter, when I began reading, especially when I got to the “we never did dishes till me ran out and then we put them in the bathtub and threw them like frisbees” I rolled my eyes with the “it’s too cutesy and deliberate.” But then, as it went further, I saw it as Chloe romanticizing her older sister and thought some of what she said couldn’t be relied on. Then I got to the scene where Chloe leaves the town with the boys, in the car, and as the boys get further away they turn from being enamored of Ruby to calling her a bitch, a slut. Suddenly, Ruby’s magic doesn’t work and she is seen, well, the way you would see the girl who peaked at high school and never left.

    Except Ruby is magic. Magical. Is it witchcraft? I’m not sure what. I’ve seen one theory where Ruby is the ghost of the drowned town. So — bottom line, because I see Ruby as being bigger than life, it works, because I buy into the supernatural aspect working in this story: the dead girl brought to life who appears to be alive to those who live in the town, Chloe’s own death erased, etc. The lily has to be gilded in order to show: there is something wrong with the lily. It’s not just one boy that loves her which makes sense but every boy? Really? That’s odd — yes — and unnatural. Because Ruby is unnatural.

    If this were a film, I’d almost imagine a scene where Chloe sees herself in a room, a house, a town and someone else would see abandoned buildings and nothing there except a crazy girl talking to herself and people who aren’t there — maybe none of this is supernatural but it’s about a crazy girl living in the woods in New York state.

  3. I can’t wait to read this one! Skipped the comments because I’m afraid of spoilers, but let me say that I adore the cover. Nice work, Design Team!

  4. Hey there, new follower!

    I’ve been wanting to read this book, but my copy accidently slipped to the bottom of my TBR pile as I kept adding to it. I think I’m gonna have to go dig for it because you brought back all that initial excitement I had when I first got it. Thanks for that!!!!


  5. Sarah Couri says

    Liz, I put off reading your review until after posting. But I wanted to come over here and enthuse without wearing my Printz glasses for a moment. I really loved this book. And I’ll admit it, a huge portion of my love is for Ruby, or at least Chloe’s version of Ruby. I love that at heart this is the story of what a sister-shaped hole feels like. The story gives me chills, yes, and, yes, it’s depicting a twisted and strange sisterly relationship…but the powerful love that’s shown, even with all its disturbing pieces — that feels absolutely right.

  6. Sarah, lately anymore I avoid reviews of books I plan on reading & reviewing myself. A “sister shaped hole”. Yes, yes, yes. And in terms of “sticking”, this book has stuck in my head something fierce; phrases, moments, and still having the pieces moving in my head, putting them together, seeing new possibilities.

    Lori, I’m looking forward to what you think.

    Amber, it’s a great cover, and it’s even better after you’ve read the book because it is so appropriate.