Follow This Blog: RSS feed
Neverending Search
Inside Neverending Search

On practicing safe search: fine tuning, privacy-friendly searches, and learning more


As librarians, we need to be concerned about privacy. ALA’s Policy Statement on Privacy reminds us

Libraries, librarians, and library workers have an ethical obligation, expressed in the ALA Code of Ethics, to preserve users’ right to privacy and prevent any unauthorized use or disclosure of users’ personally identifiable information or the data associated with their use of the library’s resources.

Just as we protect the confidentiality of user borrowing records, we need to prepare our students to protect their own privacy online.

Fine tuning the usual suspects

We might begin by encouraging students to be aware of their privacy options when they use old familiar tools.

Using Google’s Privacy Checkup you can weigh the value of personalized, faster, more convenient services against privacy and data protection. The checkup allows users to control settings for Web and App Activity; Location History; Device Information (your contacts, calendars, apps and other device data); Voice and Audio Activity (saving your voice and accompanying audio); YouTube Search History (saving your YouTube searches); and YouTube Watch History (saving the videos you watch to your account).

Bing’s Stay in Control of Your Privacy Page offers opportunities to view and delete information about  Bing search activity; to clear data collected during use of Cortana and Edge; to clear location information; to manage what Cortana knows about you; to adjust settings on Windows devices, apps, Xbox, and Office Products, Skype; as well as the ability to adjust ad and marketing services.

YouTube offers privacy settings and Facebook offers Privacy Setting and Tools.

Making more private search friendships

We can also share a growing array of search options that are designed with privacy in mind.

Yes, Google and Bing do have competitors in the world of search and one contributing factor just might be that private search engines are addressing the issue of privacy.

Among the indicators of this shift is the slight dip in market share noted by NetMarketShare’s tracking of Search Engine Market Share. (Google dropped from 74.94% in May 2016 to 69.97% in May 2018. While the little guys are showing only tiny percentages, this is a trend worth noting.)

The growing number of private search tools promising safer, more private searches that do not store your data and browsing history, may be worth an introduction and some promotion on library websites or device dashboards.

Here are some privacy-friendly options:

1. Swisscows may be my favorite recent discovery.  A product of the Swiss tech company, Hulbee AG, Swisscows is proud of its heritage. The site notes: servers are located in Switzerland and neither the US nor other data snoopers can get their hands on this information. Search topics, IP addresses and personal information, are not stored or used. Swisscows will not track your profile. The interface is clean, highly attractive and ad-free.

And I am kinda smitten with its semantic search. Using AI and machine learning, Swisscows is an intelligent answer agent that learns to intuitively respond to your questions.  Select the question mark to the right of the search box to select a region to get more relevant results. Click on any of the tiles on the left of the results to further refine your search with suggested terms.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 2.49.33 PM Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 2.54.19 PM

2. StartPage offers Google results and its post-search filters with the additional promise of privacy.  StartPage acts as an intermediary, stripping out the tracking cookies and offering anonymous results tScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.14.17 PMhrough its proxy features. It does not store your IP address. It does not remember your past searches and will not trap you in a filter bubble, presenting you with a refreshingly objective internetAdvanced Search is available and a Bookmark feature allows you to choose to store your search.

3. DuckDuckGo may be the safer search that is most popular among K12 teachers. It does not track your searches. It does not store your search history and so, it has nothing to sell to advertisers.DuckDuckGo also retrieves an ad-free search. Little icons near the results’ URLs suggest the source of the result.

A DuckDuckGo Chrome extension requiring extra permissions, promises to block hidden trackers on the sites you visit, take you to encrypted versions of sites when possible, and expose poor privacy practices when known.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.45.13 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.45.04 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.45.34 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.51.00 PM

4. Yippy not only offers a private search, it offers handy search clusters.  That is, it organizes your results into categories. This trick can be very useful when young searchers are meeting a topic for the first time or when you have a limited vocabulary in a particular area of knowledge. “Exploding” the plus signs allows you to browse any subtopics. Another nice feature allows you to choose to open results in new windows or to preview in the search itself.  Oddly, Yippy returned no results for my test “filter bubble” search.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 2.37.37 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 2.32.49 PM

5. Qwant is another private search. Attractively displaying news and trending topics on the screen pre-search, the European tool promises privacy first, unbiased results and panoramic search in 26 interface languages.

We strongly believe that what you search on the Web is an important part of your privacy. Qwant never records your searches and never uses your personal data for advertising or other purposes.

Check out Qwant’s Qwick search shortcuts.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 3.08.17 PM Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 3.10.03 PM

Qwant Junior offers an appropriate selection of intriguing hot trends featured on its homepage and claims to be

the first search engine dedicated to children, which allows them to learn in a safe environment.  Search results are checked to filter out any inappropriate content. Also Qwant Junior puts forward results that have recognized educational value.

Content in the following four categories are deemed inappropriate for children and filtered: pornography, violence, drug consumption, and hate speech. No personal data and browsing histories are not stored by Qwant Junior.

Search engines not specifically designed to be secure for children are also blocked which may limit the range of results.

A special Qwant Junior version is available for educators and students.

A nice reverse search learning game offers kiddos the opportunities to guess the keyword or phrase that brought up the shared image result pages. (It’s just a bit clunky in terms of French translation.)

Qwant Mobile is available at the App Store and at Google Play.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 3.15.23 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 3.15.37 PM
6. Discrete Search calls itself the search engine that puts privacy first. Featuring a particularly clean interface it was designed from the ground up with privacy as its core value.
Discrete Search works by intercepting searches that might be tracked from processing and redirecting them to its own privacy-enhanced search engine when it is set as your default search. It features an expiring browser history after 15 minutes of inactivity. Like several others in this group, Discrete Search is supported by sponsored ads that appear on top of the other results.
Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 3.41.52 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-21 at 1.24.33 PM
7. Oscobo is another search created to protect user privacy. Oscobo does not store personal information and encrypts connections between your connection between and Oscobo’s servers. A Perfect-Forward Secrecy feature prevents others from intercepting or decrypting search queries.
While this video was created to promote the Oscobo search, it presents the privacy situation clearly for students to understand, paying particular attention to just how much Google knows about you and sells relating to you, as well as your socioeconomic portrait.

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 4.05.22 PMScreen Shot 2018-07-22 at 7.33.54 PM

Screen Shot 2018-07-21 at 4.05.35 PM

On learning more together
Check out the following instructional resources to supports students in protecting their own digital privacy.

From Common Sense Media:

From Media Smarts Canada: Digital Issues: Privacy

Joyce Valenza About Joyce Valenza

Joyce is an Assistant Professor of Teaching at Rutgers University School of Information and Communication, a technology writer, speaker, blogger and learner. Follow her on Twitter: @joycevalenza

Speak Your Mind