Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: The Winter Prince

The Winter Prince by Elizabeth Wein. Atheneum. 1993. Read ebook edition from Open Road Media, 2013. Personal copy.

winterprince Review: The Winter PrinceThe Plot: Medraut is the oldest son of King Artos of Britain, but he can never be Prince. He can never be King. He can never be his father’s heir. He can never have what his younger brother, Prince Lleu, has — not because of anything Medraut has or has not done.

Not because of skills or ability or talent; no.

The reason that the young, arrogant Lleu is heir and favored son is because of the circumstances of their births. Lleu is the legitimate son of Artos and his wife, Ginevra. Medraut is the elder but he is illegitimate, and (as is only known by a handful of people) Medraut’s mother is Morgause, the king’s sister.

Medraut must watch from the sidelines at all that Lleu gets and is expected to get. His feelings towards his younger half-brother are complex, but it is not until his mother visits the royal household that Medraut is forced to make a choice, between his father and his mother, between himself and his brother, between the role fate has for him and the role he wants.

The Good: Why did it take me so long to read Elizabeth Wein’s first book, when I have heard over and over again how wonderful it is? Because I’m an idiot, I guess.

The Winter Prince is a retelling of King Arthur, told from the point of view of his son Mordred. If, like me, you went on a King Arthur binge at one time in your reading life, you may recall that the earliest legends and tales do not say that the king and his son were enemies. So, here, Medraut is loved by his father and his stepmother and their two children, Princess Goewin and Prince Lleu. He is a member of the family, acknowledged (though the truth about his mother’s identity remains a secret) and loved.

From the outside, even, Medraut is favored. Several years old than the twins, he has been educated; he has traveled, to Brittany, to Byzantium, to Africa; he is a healer. He is talented, he is well liked. Medraut cannot see all that he has, because of what he does not have.

Lleu is young and handsome; he is well liked; but he is immature. One thing I loved about The Winter Prince is that even though this is told from Medraut’s point of view, and Medraut loves his younger brother, the reader sees the good things about Lleu but also sees that Lleu is, well, immature. A bit soft. For example, Lleu has no stomach for hunting, even though for the time period (and as his brother tells him) hunting is necessary to get meat to eat to survive. Lleu also sometimes has the unintentional arrogance of a protected teen: he knows he is going to be King someday. Yet, for all that — Lleu is likable. It’s just, like Medraut, the reader wonders if Lleu is really fit to become King.

The Winter Prince explores the relationship between Medraut and Lleu with the question ever-lingering in the back: will Medraut be his father’s son, loyal to his brother? Or will he be his mother’s son, and decide to do what is necessary to become king himself?

His mother’s son: Morgause doesn’t appear until half way through the book, when she escorts her younger sons to Artos’s kingdom. Morgause is a woman who plays with others, including her son and her brother. Artos was unaware of their relationship when he was with Morgause; Morgause knew, and wanted a son to use against her brother in her own quest for power. Morgause’s hold over her eldest son is such that the entire book is actually directed to her. It is a story he tells to “you,” and you is Morgause.

Surprisingly, it is the Princess Goewin who says something that creates some empathy in the reader for Morgause’s viewpoint. “Father’s kingdom, this unity, it won’t last — Lleu’s not like him, and even if he were, too much is changing too fast. It can’t last. Father would have me marry Constantine, the son of the king of Dumnonia in the south. It won’t be bad, it’s important, with all the tin mines and fishing towns. But he may as well marry me to one of my cousins and exile me to the Orcades, as he has his sister, because you can be sure I won’t sit by as queen of Dumnonia and watch Britain trickle through Lleu’s fingers. If I have to I’ll take the kingship from him by force.”

Goewin doesn’t really mean her words, but her frustration about her gender preventing her even be considered for power puts some light onto Morgause’s own actions, her manipulations of her son, her cold heartedness. And, perhaps, it explains in part why it is so hard for Medraut and Arthur to cut Morgause out of their lives.

A couple more random observations before my final raves. Medraut is in his early twenties, and Lleu and Goewin are in their late teens. Yes, this is one of those young adult books where the main protagonist is not a teen. Despite Medraut’s age, and despite his years of independence traveling and living in other countries, he is wrestling with questions that are familiar to teen readers: what will his future hold? Does he accept or reject his fate? How much control does he have for his future? Can he balance his wants and desires with those of others? And of course, all along, the reader wonders, how can this be worked out, knowing how history views Medraut, knowing that there are no stories about any children of Arthur other than Mordred.

Final raves, or why The Winter Prince is a Favorite Book Read in 2013: I adored Medraut. I adored his angst over how his fate and how his family seemed to box him into a very specific space. I loved how he could both love his younger siblings and be jealous and envious and angry at them. I loved that Wein only shows some of Medraut’s and Morgause’s relationship — there are suggestions that something more may have happened between mother and son. She shows just enough, so that the reader isn’t overwhelmed by the abuse Medraut has suffered and so that the story stays focused on Medraut and Lleu. And the ending! I was on the edge of my seat for the last few chapters, wondering where this was going, and was so very satisfied with the ending.  And I love that this is done in less than 200 pages. (Yes, the ebook says 292 pages, but it ends on page 154. The remaining pages are the first chapters of the sequel, A Coalition of Lions, and a biography of Wein.)

And, yes, I have already downloaded the second book, A Coalition of Lions. There are five books in this series; the other three are The Sunbird, The Lion Hunter, and The Empty Kingdom.

Other reviews: Greenman Review; Chachic’s Book Nook (note: spoilers for the whole series); Lack of Genius; Interview with the author at Finding Wonderland (spoilers for the whole series.)

share save 171 16 Review: The Winter Prince
About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is lizzy.burns@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. Maureen E says:

    I love this book so, SO much, and I’m glad you do too. A redemption story well done is one of my favorite things, and Elizabeth Wein does it so well here. I also think there are some really fascinating almost echoes when you compare Winter Prince and Code Name Verity–the way the narrative is set up, and the tone of it. Plus the strong first person narration. I also love how the normal images of dark and light are reversed–Medraut is the one with white hair, Lleu with dark.

    I love the rest of the series like whoa, but The Winter Prince definitely has a special place in my heart.

    • Elizabeth Burns says:

      I’m a little hesitant about the other books, only because I’m wanting more Medraut! I just loved how much was packed in such a tight narrative.

      • Maureen E says:

        Does it help if I tell you that Goewin is the narrator of the next book? ALSO–there’s a short story which you may want to read at some point which chronologically goes between TWP and Coalition of Lions. It’s called “Fire” and I’m not sure where you would find it; EWein kindly emailed it to me a few years ago. I probably have the file on my old computer even.

      • Liz says:

        They’re GREAT. Very different, but very good. TWP is the standout for me for sure, but the rest of the series is a great read!

  2. tanita says:

    SO, so, so excited to see Liz’s earlier books repackaged. She’s always been so very good at plot, and bringing to light those secret, dark places in the psyche. So many questions, so much potential for betrayal, so many choices…

    • Elizabeth Burns says:

      So many times where I went “OK is this the moment of betrayal…no, this” because I “know” the story. I loved where she ended this one and (since the first chapters of the next one were included) quite fascinated by what she decided to skip in terms of narrative. She keeps us guessing!

  3. Brandy says:

    YES! These books need more attention, though to be honest I was never able to finish this one. It was a little too real and up close for me. I did go ahead and read A Coalition of Lions and LOVED it. I finished the rest of the series this past week and adored every single minute of reading them.

  4. Elizabeth Burns says:

    Brandy, Medraut’s need was so raw. And I am looking forward to the other books even if he isn’t the lead.

    • Brandy says:

      Yes, that I could handle okay even if it was uncomfortable. It was his relationship with his mother and all the implications there that I just couldn’t deal with. I have a hard time with that stuff in any book, but Wein has a way of making you feel her characters emotions so intently that it made it impossible for me to push through. I loved the writing though. And Medraut as a character.

      • Elizabeth Burns says:

        I really appreciated that what happened between the two was left up to the imagination of the reader. I think she definitely emotionally manipulated him, and there is that “lost year”, but — well, no real details. We can paint what we want.

      • Alan Stewart says:

        Wein actually does relate a good bit of what happened during the “lost year” in yet another short story (thankfully, one a little easier to find than “Fire”). The story is ““No Human Hands to Touch” and it is narrated by Morgause. It was published in an anthology called Sirens and Other Daemon Lovers, and (as you might guess by the title) was not published as YA.

        It’s a good story — though, if you prefer your own imaginings, you might want to avoid it!

  5. Sondy says:

    My favorite of the pre-CNV books is Coalition of Lions — which was the first Elizabeth Wein book I read. Didn’t know what to expect, since it was not playing off Arthurian legend. So good! (Was my #1 Historical Fiction pick in 2003.) I wanted all the rest of the books to have more of Goewin, though! Because I liked her so much. (Kind of like you’re saying about Medraut. I guess the first one we meet wins our hearts.)

    • I read COALITION first too, and I adore Goewin. (Also, Priamos. PRIAMOS!!!)

      I’d say TWP is actually my least favorite of the series, which considering how good it is, really says something about how much I love the other books.

      • Elizabeth Burns says:

        I like Goewin and what she brings to The Winter Prince, so looking forward to her story.

  6. Elizabeth Burns says:

    Ha, maybe it is the first one making a difference! But I look forward to reading it –

  7. Jonathan Hunt says:

    I think THE SUNBIRD is the best in the series. :-)

  8. Elizabeth Burns says:

    Ok, at this point I feel like you all are telling me that the only reason The Winter Prince is my favorite is because I don’t own a Prada backpack.

    I promise, I’ll read the others!

    • Liz says:

      Ha! I TWP is my favorite and I’ve read all, so it’s possible :-D

      • Elizabeth Burns says:

        I cheated on Amazon look in this book to see that Medraut reappears. So that makes me happy. I think this summer will be a reading staycation.

  9. ewein2412 says:

    well THE SUNBIRD is my favorite too. Ner.

    • Elizabeth Burns says:

      Ha! I didn’t know authors were allowed to have favorites! (plus, I love the new covers. love love love.)

Speak Your Mind

*