Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
Adult Books 4 Teens
Inside Adult Books 4 Teens

Weekly Reviews: Mid-year Graphic Novels

Today we have three very different graphic novels.  Matt Kindt’s Red Handed, a gorgeous, full-color novel with an intricately structured plot has been the source of a bit of debate.  Kimberly over on Stacked.com, while granting the novel’s interest, found its experimental structure ultimately frustrating.  And when I gave the book to one of my teen volunteers, she had a similar reaction.  On the other hand, Booklist gave it a starred review, and PW called it “nothing short of exceptional.”  VOYA hedged somewhere in between, giving the book a 4Q for its “dazzling techniques” but just a 3P, doubting its popularity with teens.  As you’ll see from my starred review below, I side with Booklist and PW.  While I see the book’s challenges–and it required a second read for me to grasp all its intricacies–I found those challenges to be well-worth the effort.

In contrast to Red Handed, Audrey Niffenegger’s The Raven Girl is simplicity itself, having been designed (and succeeding wonderfully) as a “new fairy tale.”  Teens who know Niffenegger from the book or film of The Time Traveler’s Wife (2003) may be baffled by the change of style and topic, but Niffenegger has actually been creating illustrated books for years, with such intriguing books as The Adventuress (2005) and Three Incestuous Sisters (2006).  Personally, I find her visual works to be far more successful than her novels, and I hope teens pick up this new one.

Somewhere between these two poles of complexity we have Zander Cannon’s Heck.  In one way, this novel is a straightforward, linear story, illustrated in pure black and white.  From another angle, though, it is a sly commentary on Dante’s Inferno and much else besides.  Between these three novels, we can see the large range of artistic style, plotting, and theme in the modern graphic novel.

* KINDT, Matt. Red Handed: The Fine Art of Strange Crimes. 272p. First Second. May 2013. Tr $26.99. ISBN 978-1-59643-662-6. LC 2012025793.

red handed Weekly Reviews: Mid year Graphic NovelsAdult/High School–Kindt’s twisty, mind-bending graphic novel seems at first to tell the stories of several eccentric crimes in the town of Red Wheelbarrow: a woman who steal chairs; an art thief who uses the proceeds of his first theft to become a real art dealer; a woman who steals street signs to “write” a novel; a businessman who meticulously plans an office fight so he can sue his company. The only connecting thread at first is Detective Gould, who solves all the crimes, and an enigmatic real-estate agent named Tess. Meanwhile, Kindt intersperses the stories with a comic strip called “Tess’s True Heart”; the story of Detective Gould’s wife’s career running an art gallery; and, most provocatively, an ongoing dialogue between two unnamed characters about the nature of crime, and whether such a thing as a victimless crime truly exists. As the novel comes to its close, the crimes all fall into place as pieces of one master plan that calls into question everything Detective Gould thinks. From the town’s William Carlos Williams-inspired name to the several art-related crimes, this is a novel as much about art as it is about crime, and it should provoke much thoughtful analysis even before the connection between the crimes is made clear. Kindt’s gorgeous artwork evokes classic detective comics and masterfully distinguishes the novel’s several time-periods and settings. Though it can be enjoyed as a relatively straightforward crime caper, this novel practically begs to be reread and contemplated at length.–Mark Flowers, John F. Kennedy Library, Vallejo, CA

NIFFENEGGER, Audrey. The Raven Girl. illus. by author. 71p. Abrams. May 2013. Tr $19.95. ISBN 978-1-4197-0726-1. LC 2012039266.

raven girl 227x300 Weekly Reviews: Mid year Graphic NovelsAdult/High School–In this gorgeous illustrated story, a postman and a raven fall in love and give birth to the eponymous raven girl, who has the body of a human but speaks in raven caws and longs to be like her mother. In college, she meets a young scientist who is willing to try to turn her arms into wings. But a young man from her school has fallen in love with the raven girl and sees the scientist’s experiments as unnatural and harmful. In the acknowledgements, Niffenegger explains that she wrote the story as a “new fairy tale” to use as the basis for a dance by Wayne McGregor of the Royal Ballet in London. Ballet and fairy tales have a long intertwined history (think of Tchaikovsky’s Sleeping Beauty), and this new tale should be a glorious addition to the tradition. The beautifully understated tone perfectly captures the strangely propulsive logic of the fairy tale, and the story revels in fairy-tale themes of transformation, maturation, love, and jealousy. But the most impressive element of the book is its glorious design–from the page layout, to the paper stock, to (most importantly) Niffenegger’s beautifully hesitant pen-and-ink drawings, The Raven Girl is a delight to hold and take in. Lovers of fairy tales and some graphic novel fans should find much to love here.–Mark Flowers, John F. Kennedy Library, Vallejo, CA

CANNON, Zander. Heck. 284p. Top Shelf. Jul. 2013. Tr $19.95. ISBN 9781603093019.

Heck cover 300x179 Weekly Reviews: Mid year Graphic NovelsAdult/High School-In this cheeky re-working of Dante’s Inferno, former high school football star Heck Hammarskjöld inherits his father’s estate, only to find that it contains a gateway to Hell. Soon, with the help of Elliot, his old water boy and constant admirer, Heck has set up shop taking messages back and forth between Earth and Hell, but in one of their first excursions down, Elliot is attacked by a demon and is just barely held together by mummylike wrappings. Now, in his latest adventure, Heck and Elliot must go further into Hell than they have ever gone to deliver a letter to the husband of the woman Heck loves, battling demons both literal and figurative. While Cannon has enormous fun tweaking Dante’s conception of Hell and joking about society’s (and even the Catholic Church’s) ever-changing conceptions of what merits damnation, at heart this graphic novel is a serious morality play, with the conflicted relationship between Elliot and Heck (who feels responsible for Elliot’s condition) at its center. Cannon’s artwork-pure black-and-white tones (with no shades of gray) juxtaposed against highly cartoonish drawings-mirrors the story’s tension between uncompromising morality and satiric humor. Teens drawn in by Cannon’s quirky humor may be surprised by the challenging questions posed by this wonderful novel.-Mark Flowers, John F. Kennedy Library, Vallejo, CA

share save 171 16 Weekly Reviews: Mid year Graphic Novels
About Mark Flowers

Mark Flowers is the Young Adult Librarian at the John F. Kennedy Library in Vallejo, CA. He reviews for a variety of library journals and blogs and recently contributed a chapter to The Complete Summer Reading Program Manual: From Planning to Evaluation (YALSA, 2012). Contact him via Twitter @droogmark

Comments

  1. tombs says:

    I’m not sure that AB4T is the place for posting reviews of books such as Red Handed that may be exceptional but have no teen appeal. Mr. Flowers has good opinions, but when he offers a review and never presents a case for why teens would be interested, then he is wasting my time here. And a starred review? please. Perhaps its time for a new blog.

    • Mark Flowers says:

      Not sure where you’re getting the idea that the book has “no teen appeal.” As indicated by VOYA reviewing it, and giving it a 3P, they think it has at least some teen appeal. As for my own opinion, it’s true that I didn’t present a full out case for teen appeal on this one, partially because I tend to assume (based on long library experience) that all but the most esoteric of graphic novels have teen appeal–and are checked out more often than all but the most popular YA novels, and much more often than YA nonfiction. More to the point, I would have thought that my evocation of “classic detective comics” and “a straightforward crime caper” (both of which are popular with teens) were more than enough to point to its potential teen audience. Finally, I gave the book a starred review because it’s the best graphic novel I’ve read all year–can’t think of a better reason than that.

  2. Meghan says:

    Teen appeal is so subjective. Perhaps the teens you work with wouldn’t go for this particular graphic novel but, by sharing other reviews and giving a thoughtful review himself, Mark is putting in on the radar screen of librarians or professionals who work with teens who may have an interest. They are out there. The books reviewed on AB4T are not given a stamp of “universal teen appeal”, in my experience. The blog helps find hidden gems, as well as obvious books with widespread appeal.

Speak Your Mind

*