Search on SLJ.com ....
Subscribe to SLJ
Follow This Blog: RSS feed
A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy
Inside A Chair, A Fireplace & a Tea Cozy

Review: Divergent

Divergent by Veronica Roth. Katherine Tegen Books, an imprint of Harper Collins. 2011. Reviewed from ARC from publisher.

divergent 198x300 Review: DivergentThe Plot: In a future Chicago, a person is born into one of five factions. Each faction lives according to an overall guiding belief system. Abnegation: being selfless. Amity: peace and love. Candor: honesty. Dauntless: courage. Erudite: knowledge. Each faction pursues different professions, wears different clothes, has different lifestyles and culture and ethics. Abnegation runs everything, with the belief that selfless people aren’t corrupted by power. Dauntless protects the borders of the city.

Beatrice Prior was born into Abnegation. She dresses in gray; the most affection she sees her parents show each other is hand holding; she only sees herself in a mirror on the days her mother cuts her hair. She is sixteen and the day is fast approaching when she will need to decide which faction to chose to live in for the rest of her life. Once that decision is made, it will be “faction before blood.” All ties, to Abnegation and everyone in it (her parents, her older brother Caleb) will be cut forever. A test is given, to assist teens in making their decision.

Beatrice knows she doesn’t belong in Abnegation; she knows she is not selfless. She wants something different but she doesn’t want to disappoint her parents and leave her family. Her test results are unexpected, opening up choices she didn’t know she had.

The Good: Ha ha, some may say, how unbelievable, a test at 16 that decides your future! Unbelievable? Have you heard of the SAT? While we don’t live in a world that requires “faction before blood” and abandoning the past when one makes a choice about the future, the decision made by teens at that time do shape their future. Selecting a university can impact career, friendships, family, partner, where one ends up living, just as deciding not to go to university, to join the military, to go to work right away, also influences living choices.

Why factions? “It is not ideology, religious belief, race, or nationalism that is to blame for a warring world. Rather, they determined that it was the fault of human personality — of humankind’s inclination toward evil, in whatever form that is. They divided into factions that sought to eradicate those qualities they believed responsible for the world’s disarray.” Believe that aggression causes the world’s problems? Join Amity, to use peace to overcome that quality. And so on.

It is impossible to read Divergent and not think, “what faction would I be in?” I’m too selfish for Abnegation, too cynical for Amity, not blunt enough for Candor, not brave enough for Dauntless, and not clever enough for Erudite. But I like working with others to achieve things, like Abnegation, or keeping the peace, like Amity; I value honesty, like Candor, can stand up for myself and others, like Dauntless, and value knowledge like Erudite.

When I first heard about Divergent, I thought, “who would pick Abnegation?” Roth paints a warm picture of people who get along because they think of others; the type of world where, when the dinner party is over, everyone gets up to help. I also found it fascinating how a faction controlled every aspect of a person’s life. Not just “faction before blood,” but also clothes (Abnegation wears gray, Candor black and white, Dauntless black); where they live; their houses; even the food they eat. Self-selection into factions, “like” people living and interacting only with “like” people creates some uniformity of characters (all the Dauntless love piercings and tattoos!), but there is also diversity and individuality.

All these factions work together, like a perfect puzzle, to create a perfect society. Well, the intent was to create a perfect society, but can people really be so divided and a society remain whole? Does “faction before blood” really mean “faction instead of blood”? Beatrice — now called Tris — makes her choice and struggles to succeed. Divergent is about more, though, than factions. Tris discovers truths about her society; she is forced to make even more choices, ones that will not just impact herself but impact all in her world. Divergent is about more than exploring a structured world; it’s also action packed, as Tris moves from child to full member of her chosen faction, undergoing initiations and discovering who she really is.

What else? Yes, there is a romance for Tris! It is a romance between two strong individuals, a romance that has both flirtation and respect.

For terrific, nuanced world building; for an amazingly mature romance; for a strong main character that is just the perfect mix of confidence and doubt; for leaving some conclusions for the reader to make; and for being a book I just gobbled up; Divergent is one of my Favorite Books Read in 2011.

Presenting Lenore knows her dystopia young adult novels; her review of Divergent calls it ”a high-stakes, clever, compelling novel.” (Warning: slight spoiler there about what faction Tris selects. So don’t click if you don’t want to know; on the other hand, Tris makes her choice by page 47).

share save 171 16 Review: Divergent
About Elizabeth Burns

Looking for a place to talk about young adult books? Pull up a chair, have a cup of tea, and let's chat. I am a New Jersey librarian. My opinions do not reflect those of my employer, SLJ, YALSA, or anyone else. On Twitter I'm @LizB; my email is lizzy.burns@gmail.com.

Comments

  1. Lenore says:

    Oops! I guess I should’ve had a spoiler warning :) I just thought her choice was so obvious, I didn’t even think about it!!

  2. tanita says:

    Ooooh. This sounds like we’ll see it again on the Cybils.
    This will appeal to British readers as well, the O/A level shifting starts as early as what for us would be 7th grade…

  3. Sondy says:

    The first review of this I read made it sound like another dystopian in a society I don’t believe would ever really happen on earth. You made it sound much more compelling. I will definitely be reading this.

    Another thing you got me thinking about: I have a feeling my good-girl sixteen-year-old self might well have chosen Abnegation, or maybe Erudite. My forty-six year-old self would probably NOT choose that way. So it raises the question: Would being in a faction have inhibited the changes that have come to me as I’ve matured? Sounds like lots to think about!

  4. Sondy says:

    Another thing I got to thinking about: I bet the divorce rate would be lowest in Abnegation! Because, in my opinion, affairs are inherently selfish. Do you think it would be higher in Candor, where people freely admit when they are attracted to someone else’s spouse (or would talking to your spouse about it take out the danger to the marriage?), or in Amity, where all that love might spill over the boundaries of marriage? (I’ll have to read the book and see what I think!) I wonder what would happen if people in Candor DID try to keep secrets – especially teens who haven’t made their choice yet? Oh, there’s clearly lots to muse over, just from your description. I will definitely have to read the book….

  5. Sounds interesting, but I’m afraid I’d be constantly getting sidetracked by the fact that one faction name is an adjective while the rest are all nouns….

  6. Angela Carstensen Liz B says:

    Lenore, ha! I can’t wait to chat in person about this one, because I have some very spoilery type things I want to hash out about the ending & how this world works.

    Tanita, oh, I didn’t even think about how outside the US, education systems sort children out even younger in terms of future careers. And the testing outside the US. And we all know about the OWL levels.

    Sondy, these are the types of things I wonder about for world building like this. And yes…it turns out that people are both more and less than their specified faction.

    RM1, I didn’t even notice that!

  7. Michelle says:

    I loved this book and can’t wait to chat with you and Lenore about it! I can’t seem to find a thing about this book that I didn’t like. The characters were all interesting in their own way, the world of the factions was compelling and the plot was just the right amount of action. I have to say that I was appreciative that Roth didn’t fall into the trap of creating a book that’s first in a series that forgoes an interesting plot in order to set up further books. I appreciated that she got down to brass tacks and built the story while telling the story.

Trackbacks

  1. [...] my review of Divergent, I didn’t reveal a significant choice the main character, Tris, made early on in the book. [...]

Speak Your Mind

*